Leaving AI to the Experts Isn’t an Option

I put my foot in it again!  To those who know me well that will not be a surprise. I had just met a new neighbour of a friend and was explaining what I do for a living.  Somehow this morphed into a conversation about my wariness of key performance indicators (KPIs) and AI.  It was only then that I asked my neighbour what he did.  It turned out that he is a professor in a business school specialising in operational efficiency! Please let the ground swallow me up!

It strikes me that many of us with a view on AI fear that our thoughts may not be well developed when put under the microscope.  While discussion of AI seems to be everywhere, what does this mean in practice?  In particular, what does it mean for those of us who have responsibilities in the tax space?  We are told that the change will be dramatic but what might that really mean?

I do not claim any special understanding.  But I hope that in sharing my own experience it will encourage you to engage with the changes we face.

In the tax space we not only need to adapt our own working practices but recognise that HMRC intends to dramatically change how it works.

I recently attended the annual HMRC Stakeholder Conference which is its flagship promotional event in the year.  A key theme was the use of digital technology and making the best use of AI. Later in the year HMRC will be publishing its AI strategy.  It has the bold ambition of being the best AI enabled tax authority in the world.  This will allow it to do more with less. We have already seen HMRC seeking a better understanding of underlying accounting records to reduce the tax gap.  This might be thought of as a focus on tax ‘inputs’ as well as tax ‘outputs’ such as tax computations.  Many of us are aware that our accounting records are not always set up as well as they might be for tax purposes. We all need to pay attention to this.

But what can AI mean now to those of us dealing with tax issues for our own charities?

Recently, in my own charity we feel that we have benefited immensely from what AI can contribute to our tax work.  With any change of working practice, it has to be acknowledged there are risks as well as benefits.

Some of these learnings have been:

Use AI as a matter of habit

Simply put, the more you use AI, the more useful you will find it.

Be prepared to experiment

In our busy working lives, we do not want to waste time.  Experimenting can feel like a risk.  But if we develop an AI mindset it will open many new opportunities. Initially, I was deeply suspicious of the ability of AI to prepare such good summaries from a transcript.  I was pleased to discover that my preconceived ideas were wrong.

Exercise professional oversight of AI outputs

From a tax perspective this is perhaps the most important warning!  The standard of written AI outputs can be so impressive that we feel that they must be right!  But this is not always the case. For example, the AI solution will only deal with the parameters that have been set for it. The AI outputs should be weighed up in the same way as any other opinion.

Where you can, work on AI tasks with others

I have learned so much by working with colleagues who are on the same AI journey as I am. I encourage you to learn from shared experience wherever you can.

Consider how you continue to use your professional advisors

AI will result in significant changes in the use of professional advisors.  We have already seen cases where AI has tipped the balance to not needing advisers and making savings.  But this is a tricky balance as the AI solution is not always right!

Don’t be afraid!

We are all human! We may feel threatened when tasks that once took us a long time no longer do so.  We need a mindset that does not see this as undermining us or the value of what we do.

I believe that AI can enable us to work more efficiently, have better resources and reduce tax risk for our charities.  This is particularly important as we face the prospect of a much more effective HMRC.

And what about my neighbour who knew so much more than me about what I freely shared with him? Well, he seemed to agree! It left me feeling that we should not leave these issues entirely with the experts.  This is especially true with AI.  We all need to engage with it and not leave AI to happen to us – even if we are not as qualified as we might be.

The real question is not whether AI will change the way that we work.  It is whether we choose to be part of that change. What are you going to do?

Richard Bray

Chair, Charity Tax Group