Charitable rates relief, multiple site occupation and trading – Court of Appeal decision

The Court of Appeal gave judgment on 28 May 2021 confirming the established position on the application of ratings law to a trading charity which occupies multiple sites (Nuffield Health v London Borough of Merton [2021] EWCA Civ 826). BDB Pitmans acted for the charity. Nicola Evans summarises the case below – this article was originally published here and is reproduced with the permission of the author.

Background

Nuffield Health (the Charity) is a registered charity with a charitable purpose to advance, promote and maintain health and healthcare and prevent, relieve and cure sickness and ill health, all for the public benefit. The Charity operates a number of hospitals, medical centres and fitness and well-being centres across multiple sites nationwide.

Where a charity occupies and uses a site wholly or mainly for charitable purposes, it qualifies for mandatory charitable relief (at 80%) from business rates on the site.

The Charity applied for charity relief on its fitness and well-being site in Merton. The London Borough of Merton (the council) refused and the Charity applied to court for a declaration of its entitlement to the relief. The court granted the declaration at first instance and the council appealed to the court of Appeal.

Ratings law v charity law

At trial at first instance, the council had raised an argument that the test for relief (requiring that the Charity’s use of the hereditament be ‘wholly or mainly for charitable purposes’) meant that the Charity had to satisfy the council that its use at the hereditament was for the public benefit, ie a local public benefit test applied by the council for the purpose of ratings law, distinct from the charity law test applicable across the charity’s operations overall and regulated by the Charity Commission. That argument formed the main ground on appeal to the Court of Appeal.

The majority of the Court of Appeal (Peter Jackson and Nugee LJJ, David Richards LJ dissenting) dismissed the argument. After extensive and detailed analysis set out in the judgment, they found that, in the case of a registered charity whose purposes are (by definition) exclusively charitable, it was sufficient for a ratings billing authority to enquire if the hereditament was being used (wholly or mainly) by the charity for those purposes (in contrast to some other purpose, eg for investment or fundraising). The majority reached this decision notwithstanding that, on the facts before them, they would not have found that the use of the site was for the public benefit.

Charity trading and fundraising

The council also advanced an argument that the Charity’s use of the site was mainly for fundraising. It was argued that the Charity occupied the site for two purposes – to carry out its purposes and to raise funds by trading. The Court of Appeal did not agree – the fact that the Charity is a trading charity did not mean that it occupied mainly for fundraising.

Conclusion

The decision offers a helpful clarification of the law in this area where ratings law might have clashed with charity law. It supports a simpler test which can be applied consistently across billing authorities and would not risk distortion of activities by charities operating over multiple sites. The decision also keeps the difficult question of public benefit within the jurisdiction of the Charity Commission.

The decision on trading is also helpful, making clear that a charity which is carrying out ‘primary purpose’ trading onsite should not, for that reason, be regarded as using the site for a purpose other than carrying out its charitable purposes.

Comments

  1. krxxzlmbtu says:

    Muchas gracias. ?Como puedo iniciar sesion?

  2. Edwardfruse says:

    olympe: olympe casino – olympe casino en ligne

  3. Davidnoima says:

    Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher: kamagra livraison 24h – Acheter Kamagra site fiable

  4. BradleyvermA says:

    achat kamagra: Achetez vos kamagra medicaments – Kamagra Commander maintenant

  5. PeterFredy says:

    Cialis generique prix Tadalafil achat en ligne Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne tadalmed.com

  6. BillieGlink says:

    Acheter Kamagra site fiable: kamagra gel – kamagra en ligne

  7. BradleyvermA says:

    kamagra pas cher: Achetez vos kamagra medicaments – acheter kamagra site fiable

  8. PeterFredy says:

    cialis prix Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance Cialis generique prix tadalmed.com

  9. BillieGlink says:

    Acheter Cialis: Acheter Viagra Cialis sans ordonnance – Acheter Cialis tadalmed.shop

  10. RobertArbip says:

    https://pharmafst.shop/# pharmacie en ligne

  11. BradleyvermA says:

    Cialis generique prix: Tadalafil achat en ligne – Acheter Viagra Cialis sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop

  12. PeterFredy says:

    kamagra en ligne kamagra 100mg prix Kamagra Commander maintenant

  13. BernardCruiz says:

    cialis prix: Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance – Cialis sans ordonnance 24h tadalmed.shop

  14. RobertArbip says:

    https://pharmafst.shop/# pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale

  15. BillieGlink says:

    pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – pharmacie en ligne pharmafst.com

  16. BernardCruiz says:

    cialis sans ordonnance: Tadalafil 20 mg prix en pharmacie – Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop

  17. BradleyvermA says:

    pharmacie en ligne livraison europe: Pharmacie en ligne France – pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmafst.com

  18. PeterFredy says:

    acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance Pharmacies en ligne certifiees Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe pharmafst.shop

  19. RobertArbip says:

    https://tadalmed.shop/# Cialis en ligne

  20. BillieGlink says:

    vente de mГ©dicament en ligne: Pharmacies en ligne certifiees – pharmacie en ligne france fiable pharmafst.com

  21. BernardCruiz says:

    pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique: Pharmacies en ligne certifiees – pharmacie en ligne livraison europe pharmafst.com

  22. BradleyvermA says:

    п»їpharmacie en ligne france: Pharmacies en ligne certifiees – pharmacie en ligne pharmafst.com

  23. PeterFredy says:

    Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher cialis generique Cialis sans ordonnance pas cher tadalmed.com

  24. BernardCruiz says:

    acheter kamagra site fiable: Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher – Acheter Kamagra site fiable

  25. RobertArbip says:

    https://pharmafst.shop/# Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe

  26. BillieGlink says:

    Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne: cialis generique – Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher tadalmed.shop

  27. BradleyvermA says:

    Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne: Cialis sans ordonnance 24h – Cialis sans ordonnance 24h tadalmed.shop

  28. BernardCruiz says:

    kamagra pas cher: kamagra pas cher – kamagra livraison 24h

  29. PeterFredy says:

    pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmafst.shop

  30. RobertArbip says:

    https://pharmafst.shop/# pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es

  31. BillieGlink says:

    Cialis generique prix: Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance – cialis generique tadalmed.shop

  32. BradleyvermA says:

    Kamagra pharmacie en ligne: acheter kamagra site fiable – kamagra pas cher

  33. BernardCruiz says:

    Kamagra pharmacie en ligne: kamagra 100mg prix – achat kamagra

  34. RobertArbip says:

    https://tadalmed.com/# Acheter Viagra Cialis sans ordonnance

  35. PeterFredy says:

    Tadalafil 20 mg prix en pharmacie Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne cialis generique tadalmed.com

  36. BillieGlink says:

    Tadalafil achat en ligne: Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne – Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop

  37. BradleyvermA says:

    Tadalafil achat en ligne: Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance – Cialis en ligne tadalmed.shop

  38. BernardCruiz says:

    Achetez vos kamagra medicaments: kamagra en ligne – achat kamagra

  39. RobertArbip says:

    https://tadalmed.com/# cialis prix

  40. PeterFredy says:

    Kamagra Commander maintenant kamagra pas cher kamagra en ligne

  41. BernardCruiz says:

    cialis generique: cialis sans ordonnance – Acheter Cialis tadalmed.shop

  42. BradleyvermA says:

    Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher: cialis prix – Cialis sans ordonnance 24h tadalmed.shop

  43. BillieGlink says:

    achat kamagra: acheter kamagra site fiable – Kamagra Commander maintenant

  44. RobertArbip says:

    https://tadalmed.com/# Cialis sans ordonnance 24h

  45. BernardCruiz says:

    kamagra en ligne: kamagra livraison 24h – Achetez vos kamagra medicaments

  46. RobertArbip says:

    https://pharmafst.com/# п»їpharmacie en ligne france

  47. BernardCruiz says:

    Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance: Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance – Tadalafil 20 mg prix en pharmacie tadalmed.shop

  48. BernardCruiz says:

    Cialis sans ordonnance 24h: Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance – Cialis sans ordonnance pas cher tadalmed.shop

  49. BernardCruiz says:

    kamagra pas cher: achat kamagra – kamagra pas cher

  50. RobertArbip says:

    https://tadalmed.com/# Acheter Cialis

  51. BernardCruiz says:

    Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher: Acheter Viagra Cialis sans ordonnance – cialis prix tadalmed.shop

  52. BernardCruiz says:

    pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne – п»їpharmacie en ligne france pharmafst.com

  53. RobertArbip says:

    http://pharmafst.com/# pharmacie en ligne

  54. PeterFredy says:

    acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance pharmafst.shop

  55. BillieGlink says:

    pharmacie en ligne fiable: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie en ligne france fiable pharmafst.com

  56. BernardCruiz says:

    cialis sans ordonnance: Acheter Cialis – Cialis en ligne tadalmed.shop

  57. BradleyvermA says:

    achat kamagra: kamagra gel – kamagra 100mg prix

  58. RobertArbip says:

    http://tadalmed.com/# Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne

  59. BernardCruiz says:

    pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale: Livraison rapide – pharmacie en ligne france pas cher pharmafst.com

  60. BillieGlink says:

    Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne: Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance – Cialis en ligne tadalmed.shop

  61. PeterFredy says:

    Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance Tadalafil 20 mg prix en pharmacie tadalmed.com

  62. Stevenhaump says:

    Medicine From India: medicine courier from India to USA – MedicineFromIndia

  63. Michaelbak says:

    Rx Express Mexico: mexico drug stores pharmacies – mexico pharmacy order online

  64. Dannygroke says:

    pet meds without vet prescription canada: Canadian pharmacy shipping to USA – canadian pharmacy ed medications

  65. Walterowene says:

    https://expressrxcanada.shop/# pharmacy wholesalers canada

  66. MichaelTax says:

    indian pharmacy world pharmacy india medicine courier from India to USA

  67. Stevenhaump says:

    Medicine From India: MedicineFromIndia – Medicine From India

  68. Michaelbak says:

    canadianpharmacymeds: Buy medicine from Canada – legit canadian online pharmacy

  69. Dannygroke says:

    Medicine From India: medicine courier from India to USA – Medicine From India

  70. Walterowene says:

    http://medicinefromindia.com/# MedicineFromIndia

  71. MichaelTax says:

    indian pharmacy online shopping Medicine From India medicine courier from India to USA

  72. Stevenhaump says:

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican online pharmacy – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  73. Michaelbak says:

    indian pharmacy online shopping: Medicine From India – Online medicine order

  74. Dannygroke says:

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: Rx Express Mexico – medicine in mexico pharmacies

  75. Walterowene says:

    https://medicinefromindia.com/# MedicineFromIndia

  76. Stevenhaump says:

    mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: mexican online pharmacy – Rx Express Mexico

  77. MichaelTax says:

    indian pharmacy online shopping medicine courier from India to USA medicine courier from India to USA

  78. Dannygroke says:

    Rx Express Mexico: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  79. Michaelbak says:

    mexican online pharmacy: mexican online pharmacy – mexican online pharmacy

  80. Stevenhaump says:

    MedicineFromIndia: Medicine From India – indian pharmacy online

  81. MichaelTax says:

    canadian family pharmacy Express Rx Canada canada pharmacy online

  82. Michaelbak says:

    mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: mexican rx online – mexican online pharmacy

  83. Walterowene says:

    https://medicinefromindia.shop/# Medicine From India

  84. Stevenhaump says:

    medicine courier from India to USA: indian pharmacy online – indian pharmacy online shopping

  85. MichaelTax says:

    Medicine From India medicine courier from India to USA indian pharmacy online shopping

  86. Dannygroke says:

    indian pharmacy online shopping: Medicine From India – medicine courier from India to USA

  87. Walterowene says:

    https://rxexpressmexico.shop/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  88. Stevenhaump says:

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: Rx Express Mexico – mexican online pharmacy

  89. Michaelbak says:

    Medicine From India: Medicine From India – reputable indian pharmacies

  90. Dannygroke says:

    RxExpressMexico: mexican rx online – mexico pharmacy order online

  91. MichaelTax says:

    indian pharmacy online indian pharmacy online shopping Medicine From India

  92. Walterowene says:

    https://expressrxcanada.com/# buy drugs from canada

  93. Stevenhaump says:

    Rx Express Mexico: Rx Express Mexico – RxExpressMexico

  94. Michaelbak says:

    Medicine From India: indian pharmacy online – Medicine From India

  95. Dannygroke says:

    Rx Express Mexico: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – Rx Express Mexico

  96. Walterowene says:

    https://expressrxcanada.com/# best canadian online pharmacy reviews

  97. MichaelTax says:

    medicine courier from India to USA reputable indian online pharmacy indian pharmacy

  98. Michaelbak says:

    medicine courier from India to USA: MedicineFromIndia – indian pharmacy

  99. Stevenhaump says:

    canadapharmacyonline com: ExpressRxCanada – drugs from canada

  100. ElmerMek says:

    pin up: pin up casino – pin up azerbaycan

  101. Zackaryrit says:

    http://vavadavhod.tech/# vavada вход

  102. Richardnic says:

    пин ап казино официальный сайт пин ап вход пин ап казино официальный сайт

  103. KennethHic says:

    пинап казино: пинап казино – пин ап вход

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *