Supplies to local authorities – Healthwatch Hampshire VAT case

*Update* – Graham Elliott has written a second briefing providing further information following the decision in this case.

We do not, as a rule, report cases that deal with entities that are not charities, even where they are constituted as non-profit bodies, but we keep an eye out for cases which could ‘read over’ to charities, and we think that the recent Tribunal decision about VAT in the case of Healthwatch Hampshire CIC (TC05803) is an example.

The case dealt with a perennial issue, which is how to avoid input tax becoming non-recoverable in providing services that a local authority would otherwise perform, given that local authorities can reclaim VAT under S33 VATA.  The simple answer is for the body to which the activity is delegated to make a taxable charge to the local authority, and to reclaim corresponding input tax.  That is what Healthwatch Hampshire CIC tried to do, was denied that treatment by HMRC, but successfully litigated the point, and confirmed the ability to claim the VAT.  We hope that HMRC will accept the result and not attempt an appeal of what does appear to be a somewhat flimsy case.

The specific issue related to a legal requirement placed on local authorities in 2012 to outsource to a CIC (non-profit entity) the function of giving the public a sounding board to which to make comments concerning their local authority’s performance in the area of local care services.  Local authorities had no choice in this, and the entity they had to set up had to be a CIC.  Local authorities had no choice but to fund these CICs on an adequate basis. Thus far, therefore, there appeared to be a structure which was untypical of a free or open market.

Because the arrangement was regarded as a ‘creature of government’, HMRC appears to have agreed with CIPFA that the money flows from local authorities to these CICs would be outside the scope of VAT, as representing something other than consideration for taxable supplies.

It seems that Healthwatch Hampshire did not hear about that agreement, because it arranged with Hampshire County Council to charge VAT, which the latter claimed.  Importantly, for our purposes, the CIC was ‘backed’ by three charities, and these essentially provided the work and facilities that the CIC provided to the local authority.  HMRC ‘accepted’ that the charities’ supplies to the CIC were taxable, but not that the CIC’s supplies were taxable.  The result was a significant ‘sticking’ tax liability.

The charities decided to propel the CIC into the tribunal to challenge this unwarranted creation of sticking tax, and the tribunal agreed with the CIC (and with the charities that backed the CIC).  Despite the lack of a classic commercial market, and the requirement that had been placed on local authorities to fund such separate services, there was no reason to doubt that services were provided, which the local authority needed, and which benefitted the local authority by reference to enabling it to meet its statutory obligations.  All of this was performed in return for payment, and that payment was ‘consideration’.  Following an analysis of the recent Court of Appeal decision in Longridge, including extensive quotes from one of the Court’s judges, the tribunal decided that the activity was within the scope of VAT.

A separate argument that the CIC acted as a public body also left the tribunal unmoved (though that point is not of direct relevance to charities).

It is ironic that the judgement in a case which HMRC won (Longridge) formed the basis of a decision in which HMRC lost.  It seems that HMRC was cherry picking its outcomes to increase revenues.  The tribunal, however, stood in the way of that objective.

Graham Elliott is CTG’s Technical Adviser

 

Comments

  1. David Arkinstall says:

    If not successful could CIC have made a claim under section 33?

  2. Colin Crowley says:

    Does the CIPFA agreement still stand for all those who applied it or does this case now overturn their position and if so from when ?

  3. CTG says:

    The decision is under appeal so the Cipfa policy doesn’t change until the appeal is finished. CTG

  4. Mr Pea says:

    Do you know what the outcome of the appeal was?

  5. RichardFeAch says:

    http://saludfrontera.com/# mexican online pharmacies

  6. TeddyMug says:

    CuraBharat USA: CuraBharat USA – indian chemist

  7. TeddyMug says:

    india pharmacy: percocet india – online medicine india

  8. TeddyMug says:

    pharmacy in mexico city: SaludFrontera – mexico pharmacies

  9. MichaelFreed says:

    medications from india CuraBharat USA CuraBharat USA

  10. Charlesrex says:

    pharmacy india: CuraBharat USA – drugs available in india

  11. JeremyBlase says:

    https://truenorthpharm.shop/# TrueNorth Pharm

  12. TeddyMug says:

    buy oxycodone online: CuraBharat USA – how to order medicine online

  13. MichaelFreed says:

    canada cloud pharmacy canada drugs vipps approved canadian online pharmacy

  14. Charlesrex says:

    reliable canadian pharmacy: canadian pharmacy drugs online – canadian family pharmacy

  15. JeremyBlase says:

    https://truenorthpharm.shop/# the canadian pharmacy

  16. TeddyMug says:

    SaludFrontera: buying prescription drugs in mexico – farmacia mexicana online

  17. MichaelFreed says:

    vipps canadian pharmacy TrueNorth Pharm canadian pharmacy 365

  18. Charlesrex says:

    best canadian online pharmacy reviews: canadian pharmacy cheap – safe canadian pharmacy

  19. JeremyBlase says:

    http://curabharatusa.com/# online pharmacy india

  20. TeddyMug says:

    TrueNorth Pharm: TrueNorth Pharm – legitimate canadian pharmacy

  21. Charlesrex says:

    rate canadian pharmacies: best canadian pharmacy online – TrueNorth Pharm

  22. MichaelFreed says:

    TrueNorth Pharm canadian online drugstore canadian 24 hour pharmacy

  23. JeremyBlase says:

    https://curabharatusa.com/# CuraBharat USA

  24. TeddyMug says:

    CuraBharat USA: CuraBharat USA – CuraBharat USA

  25. Charlesrex says:

    CuraBharat USA: medicine online order – pharmacy online medicine

  26. StevenPoock says:

    online apotheke deutschland sicherheit und wirkung von potenzmitteln eu apotheke ohne rezept

  27. DonaldSoaks says:

    apotheke online: rezeptfreie arzneimittel online kaufen – apotheke online

  28. Enriquemib says:

    https://potenzapothekede.com/# wirkung und dauer von tadalafil

  29. Williamdor says:

    https://gesunddirekt24.com/# online apotheke rezept

  30. IsraelKip says:

    PotenzApotheke: wirkung und dauer von tadalafil – online apotheke versandkostenfrei

  31. StevenPoock says:

    online apotheke online apotheke deutschland ohne rezept internet apotheke

  32. DonaldSoaks says:

    apotheke online: Blau Kraft – online apotheke preisvergleich

  33. Enriquemib says:

    https://gesunddirekt24.com/# gГјnstige online apotheke

  34. IsraelKip says:

    cialis generika ohne rezept: tadalafil 20mg preisvergleich – medikamente rezeptfrei

  35. StevenPoock says:

    europa apotheke rezeptfreie medikamente fur erektionsstorungen tadalafil 20mg preisvergleich

  36. DonaldSoaks says:

    günstige online apotheke: Blau Kraft De – europa apotheke

  37. IsraelKip says:

    PotenzApotheke: Potenz Apotheke – online apotheke rezept

  38. StevenPoock says:

    Billig Viagra bestellen ohne Rezept Intim Gesund kamagra kaufen ohne rezept online

  39. DonaldSoaks says:

    kamagra oral jelly deutschland bestellen: kamagra oral jelly deutschland bestellen – Sildenafil Generika 100mg

  40. IsraelKip says:

    ohne rezept apotheke: potenzmittel ohne rezept deutschland – online apotheke versandkostenfrei

  41. StevenPoock says:

    medikament ohne rezept notfall Gesund Direkt 24 online apotheke preisvergleich

  42. DonaldSoaks says:

    online apotheke rezept: Gesund Direkt 24 – online apotheke deutschland

  43. IsraelKip says:

    tadalafil 20mg preisvergleich: schnelle lieferung tadalafil tabletten – ohne rezept apotheke

  44. Williamdor says:

    http://potenzapothekede.com/# tadalafil 20mg preisvergleich

  45. StevenPoock says:

    ohne rezept apotheke deutsche online apotheke erfahrungen medikamente rezeptfrei

  46. DonaldSoaks says:

    online apotheke rezept: Gesund Direkt 24 – online apotheke versandkostenfrei

  47. IsraelKip says:

    beste online-apotheke ohne rezept: medikamente rezeptfrei – online apotheke

  48. DonaldSoaks says:

    online apotheke preisvergleich: generika potenzmittel online bestellen – online apotheke

  49. IsraelKip says:

    wirkung und dauer von tadalafil: tadalafil 20mg preisvergleich – ohne rezept apotheke

  50. StevenPoock says:

    europa apotheke wirkung und dauer von tadalafil rezeptfreie medikamente fur erektionsstorungen

  51. Williamdor says:

    http://intimgesund.com/# kamagra erfahrungen deutschland

  52. Enriquemib says:

    https://gesunddirekt24.com/# online apotheke gГјnstig

  53. DonaldSoaks says:

    online apotheke rezept: diskrete lieferung von potenzmitteln – online apotheke

  54. IsraelKip says:

    preisvergleich kamagra tabletten: IntimGesund – Viagra online kaufen legal

  55. StevenPoock says:

    online apotheke preisvergleich cialis generika ohne rezept tadalafil 20mg preisvergleich

  56. Richarddough says:

    https://evertrustmeds.shop/# Ever Trust Meds

  57. Derekasync says:

    ClearMedsHub: Clear Meds Hub

  58. Dennisdeamb says:

    : ClearMedsHub

  59. MichealOrisa says:

    EverTrustMeds EverTrustMeds Ever Trust Meds

  60. Richarddough says:

    https://evertrustmeds.com/# Buy Cialis online

  61. Derekasync says:

    VitalEdge Pharma: VitalEdge Pharma – VitalEdgePharma

  62. Dennisdeamb says:

    Ever Trust Meds: buy cialis pill – buy cialis pill

  63. MichealOrisa says:

    Ever Trust Meds Cialis 20mg price in USA Ever Trust Meds

  64. Derekasync says:

    Clear Meds Hub: – Clear Meds Hub

  65. Dennisdeamb says:

    ClearMedsHub: – Clear Meds Hub

  66. Richarddough says:

    http://vitaledgepharma.com/# ed online meds

  67. MichealOrisa says:

    cheap ed drugs online erectile dysfunction medication VitalEdgePharma

  68. Derekasync says:

    ed medicines: VitalEdge Pharma – ed medications online

  69. Antonioinvek says:

    https://evertrustmeds.com/# Ever Trust Meds

  70. Dennisdeamb says:

    Ever Trust Meds: Cialis 20mg price in USA – Buy Tadalafil 5mg

  71. MichealOrisa says:

    Clear Meds Hub Clear Meds Hub Clear Meds Hub

  72. Richarddough says:

    https://evertrustmeds.shop/# Ever Trust Meds

  73. Derekasync says:

    : – Clear Meds Hub

  74. Dennisdeamb says:

    : ClearMedsHub – ClearMedsHub

  75. MichealOrisa says:

    erectile dysfunction online cheap ed medicine VitalEdge Pharma

  76. Richarddough says:

    https://vitaledgepharma.shop/# VitalEdgePharma

  77. Derekasync says:

    EverTrustMeds: Ever Trust Meds – EverTrustMeds

  78. Antonioinvek says:

    http://evertrustmeds.com/# Ever Trust Meds

  79. Dennisdeamb says:

    Ever Trust Meds: EverTrustMeds – EverTrustMeds

  80. MichealOrisa says:

    ClearMedsHub Clear Meds Hub Clear Meds Hub

  81. Richarddough says:

    http://vitaledgepharma.com/# VitalEdgePharma

  82. Derekasync says:

    Ever Trust Meds: EverTrustMeds – EverTrustMeds

  83. Dennisdeamb says:

    : – Clear Meds Hub

  84. MichealOrisa says:

    ClearMedsHub Clear Meds Hub

  85. Richarddough says:

    https://vitaledgepharma.com/# erection pills online

  86. Derekasync says:

    ClearMedsHub: Clear Meds Hub – Clear Meds Hub

  87. Dennisdeamb says:

    : ClearMedsHub

  88. MichealOrisa says:

    VitalEdgePharma cheap ed VitalEdge Pharma

  89. Antonioinvek says:

    http://evertrustmeds.com/# Cialis 20mg price

  90. Richarddough says:

    https://vitaledgepharma.shop/# VitalEdge Pharma

  91. Derekasync says:

    VitalEdgePharma: VitalEdge Pharma – VitalEdge Pharma

  92. Dennisdeamb says:

    ClearMedsHub: ClearMedsHub – ClearMedsHub

  93. MichealOrisa says:

    Ever Trust Meds Ever Trust Meds Cialis 20mg price in USA

  94. Richarddough says:

    http://vitaledgepharma.com/# VitalEdge Pharma

  95. Dennisdeamb says:

    VitalEdge Pharma: VitalEdge Pharma – VitalEdge Pharma

  96. Derekasync says:

    Clear Meds Hub: ClearMedsHub

  97. MichealOrisa says:

    EverTrustMeds Ever Trust Meds Cialis without a doctor prescription

  98. Jamesdesse says:

    Best online Indian pharmacy: indian pharmacy – Best Indian pharmacy

  99. EugeneOvedo says:

    Mexican pharmacy ship to USA: mexico pharmacy – Online Mexican pharmacy

  100. AaronAromo says:

    Best online Indian pharmacy: india pharmacy – Best Indian pharmacy

  101. Jamesbat says:

    mexico pharmacy mexico pharmacy Best Mexican pharmacy online

  102. Jamesdesse says:

    mexico pharmacy list: BajaMedsDirect – mexican pharmacy

  103. EugeneOvedo says:

    mexico pharmacy: Mexican pharmacy price list – Online Mexican pharmacy

  104. AaronAromo says:

    Mexican pharmacy ship to USA: Mexican pharmacy ship to USA – Mexican pharmacy price list

  105. MonteQuelt says:

    https://maplecarerx.shop/# Canadian pharmacy prices

  106. Jamesbat says:

    india pharmacy Best online Indian pharmacy Indian pharmacy ship to USA

  107. Jamesdesse says:

    Indian pharmacy international shipping: Indian pharmacy ship to USA – Best Indian pharmacy

  108. AaronAromo says:

    Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US: canadian pharmacy – Canadian pharmacy prices

  109. Jamesbat says:

    MapleCareRx Canadian pharmacy prices Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US

  110. EugeneOvedo says:

    canadian pharmacy: Canadian pharmacy prices – Canadian pharmacy online

  111. AaronAromo says:

    Online Mexican pharmacy: Mexican pharmacy ship to USA – Mexican pharmacy ship to USA

  112. MonteQuelt says:

    https://bajamedsdirect.com/# Mexican pharmacy ship to USA

  113. Jamesbat says:

    Canadian pharmacy online Canadian pharmacy prices MapleCareRx

  114. EugeneOvedo says:

    Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US: MapleCareRx – Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US

  115. Jamesdesse says:

    Indian pharmacy ship to USA: online medicine sites in india – india pharmacy online

  116. AaronAromo says:

    Online Mexican pharmacy: mexican pharmacy – mexican pharmacy

  117. Jamesbat says:

    Best Mexican pharmacy online mexican pharmacy mexico pharmacy

  118. EugeneOvedo says:

    MapleCareRx: Canadian pharmacy online – Canadian pharmacy prices

  119. AaronAromo says:

    Canadian pharmacy online: Canadian pharmacy prices – Canadian pharmacy online

  120. MonteQuelt says:

    http://bajamedsdirect.com/# Mexican pharmacy price list

  121. Jamesbat says:

    online canadian drugstore canadian discount pharmacy Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US

  122. RandyUnuse says:

    günstige online apotheke: ApothekeDirekt24 – internet apotheke

  123. BernardRix says:

    tryggt svenskt apotek pa natet: billiga lakemedel pa natet – ohne rezept apotheke

  124. MilesFrisk says:

    online apotheke gГјnstig: ApothekeDirekt24 – online apotheke deutschland

  125. PatrickatOft says:

    п»їpharmacie en ligne france pharmacie francaise livraison a domicile pharmacie francaise livraison a domicile

  126. RandyUnuse says:

    online apotheke rezept: online apotheke preisvergleich – günstigste online apotheke

  127. MilesFrisk says:

    billiga lakemedel pa natet: bestalla medicin utan recept – internet apotheke

  128. BernardRix says:

    tryggt svenskt apotek pa natet: tryggt svenskt apotek pa natet – beste online-apotheke ohne rezept

  129. PatrickatOft says:

    pharmacie en ligne fiable medicaments sans ordonnance livraison rapide pharmacie en ligne France fiable

  130. RandyUnuse says:

    Nordic Apotek: billiga läkemedel på nätet – shop apotheke gutschein

  131. MilesFrisk says:

    pharmacie en ligne France fiable: pharmacie francaise livraison a domicile – pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance

  132. BernardRix says:

    medikament ohne rezept notfall: Erfahrungen mit Online Apotheken – online apotheke rezept

  133. PatrickatOft says:

    pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance acheter medicaments en ligne pas cher commande discrete medicaments France

  134. MilesFrisk says:

    medicaments sans ordonnance livraison rapide: PharmaRapide – pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale

  135. RandyUnuse says:

    médicaments sans ordonnance livraison rapide: commande discrète médicaments France – pharmacies en ligne certifiées

  136. Wayneignob says:

    http://apothekedirekt24.com/# internet apotheke

  137. BernardRix says:

    online apotheke preisvergleich: Kamagra Deutschland Apotheke – online apotheke gГјnstig

  138. PatrickatOft says:

    online apotheke deutschland kamagra online apotheke rezept

  139. MilesFrisk says:

    acheter medicaments en ligne pas cher: pharmacie francaise livraison a domicile – pharmacie en ligne france fiable

  140. RandyUnuse says:

    NordicApotek: hälsolösningar online Sverige – internet apotheke

  141. BernardRix says:

    online apotheke rezept: kamagra – medikament ohne rezept notfall

  142. AnthonyZooky says:

    medicinali generici a basso costo: farmacia online Italia affidabile – spedizione rapida farmaci Italia

  143. DavidGek says:

    goedkope medicijnen online: geneesmiddelen zonder recept bestellen – online apotheek Nederland betrouwbaar

  144. Floydprure says:

    goedkope medicijnen online veilig online apotheek NL Holland Apotheek

  145. JamesFet says:

    apotek pa nett: apotek pa nett billigst – reseptfrie medisiner pa nett

  146. AnthonyZooky says:

    apotek uten resept med levering hjem: billige generiske legemidler Norge – billige generiske legemidler Norge

  147. DavidGek says:

    SaludExpress: comprar medicinas online sin receta médica – pedir fármacos por Internet

  148. Floydprure says:

    bestille medisiner online diskret reseptfrie medisiner pa nett apotek pa nett med gode priser

  149. FrankAloft says:

    https://farmaciafacileit.com/# Farmacie on line spedizione gratuita

  150. DavidGek says:

    farmacia online madrid: farmacias direct – farmacia en casa online descuento

  151. AnthonyZooky says:

    generieke geneesmiddelen Nederland: geneesmiddelen zonder recept bestellen – veilig online apotheek NL

  152. Floydprure says:

    NordApotek apotek pa nett med gode priser nettapotek Norge trygt og palitelig

  153. JamesFet says:

    farmacia espanola en linea economica: farmacia espanola en linea economica – farmacias online seguras

  154. DavidGek says:

    apotek på nett med gode priser: billige generiske legemidler Norge – nettapotek Norge trygt og pålitelig

  155. AnthonyZooky says:

    billige generiske legemidler Norge: NordApotek – billige generiske legemidler Norge

  156. Floydprure says:

    farmacia online Italia affidabile opinioni su farmacia online italiana FarmaciaFacile

  157. FrankAloft says:

    https://saludexpresses.shop/# pedir farmacos por Internet

  158. DavidGek says:

    bestille medisiner online diskret: bestille medisiner online diskret – nettapotek Norge trygt og pålitelig

  159. AnthonyZooky says:

    spedizione rapida farmaci Italia: comprare farmaci online all’estero – spedizione rapida farmaci Italia

  160. Floydprure says:

    medicinali generici a basso costo opinioni su farmacia online italiana ordinare farmaci senza ricetta

  161. DavidGek says:

    SaludExpress: comprar medicinas online sin receta médica – farmacia española en línea económica

  162. AnthonyZooky says:

    discrete levering van medicijnen: generieke geneesmiddelen Nederland – geneesmiddelen zonder recept bestellen

  163. Floydprure says:

    Holland Apotheek online apotheek veilig online apotheek NL

  164. JamesFet says:

    farmaci senza prescrizione disponibili online: ordinare farmaci senza ricetta – Farmacie on line spedizione gratuita

  165. DavidGek says:

    spedizione rapida farmaci Italia: opinioni su farmacia online italiana – farmaci senza prescrizione disponibili online

  166. AnthonyZooky says:

    opinioni su farmacia online italiana: Farmacia online migliore – farmaci senza prescrizione disponibili online

  167. FrankAloft says:

    https://hollandapotheeknl.com/# apotheek zonder receptplicht

  168. Floydprure says:

    kundevurderinger av nettapotek bestille medisiner online diskret billige generiske legemidler Norge

  169. DavidGek says:

    ordinare farmaci senza ricetta: medicinali generici a basso costo – FarmaciaFacile

  170. AnthonyZooky says:

    farmacia barata: pedir fármacos por Internet – farmacia online 24 horas

  171. Floydprure says:

    FarmaciaFacile opinioni su farmacia online italiana spedizione rapida farmaci Italia

  172. JamesFet says:

    farmaci senza prescrizione disponibili online: spedizione rapida farmaci Italia – medicinali generici a basso costo

  173. DavidGek says:

    nettapotek Norge trygt og pålitelig: apotek på nett – billige generiske legemidler Norge

  174. FrankAloft says:

    http://saludexpresses.com/# farmacia espanola en linea economica

  175. AnthonyZooky says:

    apotek uten resept med levering hjem: billige generiske legemidler Norge – apotek uten resept med levering hjem

  176. DavidFic says:

    real money slot Chicken Road UK real money slot Chicken Road UK casino promotions Chicken Road game

  177. Scottgor says:

    mobile Chicken Road slot app: Chicken Road slot game India – best Indian casinos with Chicken Road

  178. JosephCic says:

    UK players free spins Chicken Road: licensed UK casino sites Chicken Road – Chicken Road

  179. JosephGaing says:

    Plinko: Plinko RTP e strategie – bonus Plinko slot Italia

  180. DavidFic says:

    British online casinos with Chicken Road UK players free spins Chicken Road Chicken Road slot UK

  181. Bricelorce says:

    https://plinkoslotitalia.shop/# Plinko casino online Italia

  182. Scottgor says:

    recensione Chicken Road slot: giri gratis Chicken Road casino Italia – vincite e bonus gioco Chicken Road

  183. JosephGaing says:

    Chicken Road slot game India: Chicken Road slot game India – Chicken Road slot game India

  184. DavidFic says:

    recensione Chicken Road slot giocare Chicken Road gratis o con soldi veri slot a tema fattoria Italia

  185. Scottgor says:

    play Chicken Road casino online: Chicken Road slot game India – mobile Chicken Road slot app

  186. JosephCic says:

    how to win Chicken Road slot game: free demo Chicken Road game – secure online gambling India

  187. JosephGaing says:

    Chicken Road slot game India: free demo Chicken Road game – free demo Chicken Road game

  188. Bricelorce says:

    https://chickenroadslotitalia.com/# giri gratis Chicken Road casino Italia

  189. DavidFic says:

    giri gratis Chicken Road casino Italia giocare Chicken Road gratis o con soldi veri giocare Chicken Road gratis o con soldi veri

  190. Scottgor says:

    free demo Chicken Road game: Chicken Road slot game India – secure online gambling India

  191. JosephGaing says:

    mobile Chicken Road slot app: mobile Chicken Road slot app – Chicken Road slot game India

  192. DavidFic says:

    play Chicken Road casino online UK licensed UK casino sites Chicken Road play Chicken Road casino online UK

  193. Scottgor says:

    migliori casinò italiani con Plinko: Plinko demo gratis – scommesse Plinko online

  194. JosephCic says:

    giri gratis Chicken Road casino Italia: giocare Chicken Road gratis o con soldi veri – casino online italiani con Chicken Road

  195. Bricelorce says:

    https://chickenroadslotindia.com/# play Chicken Road casino online

  196. Martinlar says:

    buy tadalafil from india: Buy Tadalafil 20mg – Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription

  197. TimothyLah says:

    Mexican pharmacy price list mexican pharmacy Best online Mexican pharmacy

  198. BruceFlisy says:

    Sildenafil 100mg: true vital meds – Sildenafil 100mg

  199. WilliamMug says:

    http://tadalmedspharmacy.com/# tadalafil best price

  200. Martinlar says:

    Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription: tadalafil 20 mg mexico – tadalafil

  201. TimothyLah says:

    tadalafil Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription Buy Tadalafil 20mg

  202. BruceFlisy says:

    Best online Mexican pharmacy: Best online Mexican pharmacy – Legit online Mexican pharmacy

  203. AnthonyEnriz says:

    http://truevitalmeds.com/# sildenafil prices in india

  204. WilliamMug says:

    http://truevitalmeds.com/# Buy sildenafil online usa

  205. Martinlar says:

    Sildenafil 100mg price: true vital meds – sildenafil generic coupon

  206. BruceFlisy says:

    Legit online Mexican pharmacy: MedicExpress MX – safe mexican online pharmacy

  207. TimothyLah says:

    Generic tadalafil 20mg price buy tadalafil 5mg online Buy Tadalafil online

  208. WilliamMug says:

    https://tadalmedspharmacy.shop/# Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription

  209. Martinlar says:

    Best online Mexican pharmacy: mexico drug stores pharmacies – Best online Mexican pharmacy

  210. BruceFlisy says:

    Online Mexican pharmacy: MedicExpress MX – Legit online Mexican pharmacy

  211. TimothyLah says:

    tadalafil tadalafil tadalafil 20 mg over the counter

  212. AnthonyEnriz says:

    https://tadalmedspharmacy.com/# Buy Tadalafil 20mg

  213. WilliamMug says:

    https://medicexpressmx.shop/# Mexican pharmacy price list

  214. BruceFlisy says:

    Buy Tadalafil online: Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription – tadalafil brand name in india

  215. Martinlar says:

    Buy Tadalafil online: Generic tadalafil 20mg price – buy tadalafil 20mg price in india

  216. TimothyLah says:

    Online Mexican pharmacy Best online Mexican pharmacy Legit online Mexican pharmacy

  217. WilliamMug says:

    https://medicexpressmx.com/# mexican pharmacy

  218. BruceFlisy says:

    Legit online Mexican pharmacy: Legit online Mexican pharmacy – Mexican pharmacy price list

  219. Martinlar says:

    Buy Tadalafil 20mg: tadalafil – Buy Tadalafil 20mg

  220. AnthonyEnriz says:

    http://medicexpressmx.com/# Legit online Mexican pharmacy

  221. TimothyLah says:

    cheap mexican pharmacy Best online Mexican pharmacy Online Mexican pharmacy

  222. WilliamMug says:

    http://medicexpressmx.com/# Online Mexican pharmacy

  223. BruceFlisy says:

    Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription: Generic tadalafil 20mg price – cost of tadalafil

  224. Martinlar says:

    cheap 10 mg tadalafil: tadalafil 22 mg – tadalafil online without prescription

  225. TimothyLah says:

    Mexican pharmacy price list Legit online Mexican pharmacy Best online Mexican pharmacy

  226. WilliamMug says:

    https://medicexpressmx.shop/# Legit online Mexican pharmacy

  227. BruceFlisy says:

    tadalafil generic price: Buy Tadalafil 20mg – tadalafil

  228. Martinlar says:

    Sildenafil 100mg: Buy sildenafil – sildenafil

  229. AnthonyEnriz says:

    http://truevitalmeds.com/# Buy sildenafil

  230. TimothyLah says:

    tadalafil Buy Tadalafil online Buy Tadalafil online

  231. DavidAroca says:

    https://clomicareusa.shop/# Buy Clomid online

  232. Glennbog says:

    zithromax z- pak buy online: zithromax z- pak buy online – cheap zithromax

  233. Charlesnus says:

    buy zithromax online: zithromax z- pak buy online – generic zithromax

  234. DavidFug says:

    cheap zithromax ZithroMeds Online buy zithromax

  235. DavidAroca says:

    http://amoxdirectusa.com/# Buy Amoxicillin for tooth infection

  236. Glennbog says:

    Buy Clomid online: Buy Clomid online – Buy Clomid online

  237. AnthonyNem says:

    https://clomicareusa.com/# Generic Clomid

  238. Charlesnus says:

    Purchase amoxicillin online: Buy Amoxicillin for tooth infection – buy amoxicillin

  239. DavidFug says:

    Clomid for sale Clomid fertility Clomid for sale

  240. Glennbog says:

    zithromax z- pak buy online: ZithroMeds Online – generic zithromax

  241. DavidAroca says:

    http://zithromedsonline.com/# zithromax prescription online

  242. Charlesnus says:

    Purchase amoxicillin online: Amoxicillin 500mg buy online – buy amoxicillin

  243. DavidFug says:

    Buy Amoxicillin for tooth infection amoxicillin 50 mg tablets Purchase amoxicillin online

  244. Glennbog says:

    buy amoxicillin 500mg usa: where can you get amoxicillin – buy amoxil

  245. DavidAroca says:

    https://zithromedsonline.com/# cheap zithromax

  246. AnthonyNem says:

    http://amoxdirectusa.com/# Buy Amoxicillin for tooth infection

  247. Charlesnus says:

    Buy Amoxicillin for tooth infection: Purchase amoxicillin online – buy amoxicillin

  248. Glennbog says:

    Amoxicillin 500mg buy online: Amoxicillin 500mg buy online – Buy Amoxicillin for tooth infection

  249. DavidFug says:

    cheap zithromax buy zithromax ZithroMeds Online

  250. DavidAroca says:

    https://amoxdirectusa.shop/# where can i buy amoxicillin online

  251. Charlesnus says:

    Buy Clomid online: buy clomid – clomid without a prescription

  252. Glennbog says:

    how to get zithromax: zithromax z- pak buy online – cheap zithromax

  253. DavidFug says:

    ClomiCare USA ClomiCare USA Buy Clomid online

  254. Charlesnus says:

    buy finasteride: buy propecia – Propecia 1mg price

  255. DavidAroca says:

    https://amoxdirectusa.com/# Amoxicillin 500mg buy online

  256. Glennbog says:

    amoxicillin where to get: buy amoxil – Purchase amoxicillin online

  257. DavidFug says:

    AmoxDirect USA buy amoxil buy amoxil

  258. Charlesnus says:

    AmoxDirect USA: Buy Amoxicillin for tooth infection – Purchase amoxicillin online

  259. Glennbog says:

    zithromax 250: zithromax z- pak buy online – buy zithromax online

  260. DavidFug says:

    RegrowRx Online cost cheap propecia prices RegrowRx Online

  261. Charlesnus says:

    Propecia 1mg price: Propecia prescription – Propecia 1mg price

  262. Glennbog says:

    Clomid fertility: ClomiCare USA – Clomid fertility

  263. DavidFug says:

    AmoxDirect USA buy amoxicillin Buy Amoxicillin for tooth infection

  264. Kennetheloca says:

    https://neurocaredirect.com/# gabapentin capsules for nerve pain

  265. Morristic says:

    Prednisone without prescription USA: online pharmacy Prednisone fast delivery – Prednisone without prescription USA

  266. Williemaw says:

    EverLastRx: safe online pharmacy for ED pills – Tadalafil tablets

  267. MichaelNix says:

    low-cost ivermectin for Americans Stromectol ivermectin tablets for humans USA generic ivermectin online pharmacy

  268. Morristic says:

    ivermectin dose for scabies: generic ivermectin online pharmacy – generic ivermectin online pharmacy

  269. Williemaw says:

    discreet delivery for ED medication: Tadalafil tablets – price comparison tadalafil

  270. MichaelNix says:

    neuropathic pain relief treatment online FDA-approved gabapentin alternative gabapentin price canada

  271. Williemaw says:

    how to get Prednisone legally online: how to get Prednisone legally online – how to get Prednisone legally online

  272. Morristic says:

    generic gabapentin pharmacy USA: generic gabapentin pharmacy USA – order gabapentin discreetly

  273. MichaelNix says:

    online pharmacy Prednisone fast delivery prednisone 12 mg how to get Prednisone legally online

  274. RobertRof says:

    https://predniwellonline.shop/# online pharmacy Prednisone fast delivery

  275. Williemaw says:

    buy prednisone online fast shipping: online pharmacy Prednisone fast delivery – Prednisone without prescription USA

  276. Morristic says:

    generic gabapentin pharmacy USA: generic gabapentin pharmacy USA – Neurontin online without prescription USA

  277. MichaelNix says:

    Tadalafil tablets FDA-approved Tadalafil generic EverLastRx

  278. Kennetheloca says:

    https://medivermonline.shop/# generic ivermectin online pharmacy

  279. RobertRof says:

    https://predniwellonline.shop/# how to get Prednisone legally online

  280. Williemaw says:

    neuropathic pain relief treatment online: Neurontin online without prescription USA – generic gabapentin pharmacy USA

  281. Morristic says:

    FDA-approved Tadalafil generic: safe online pharmacy for ED pills – discreet delivery for ED medication

  282. MichaelNix says:

    order Stromectol discreet shipping USA order Stromectol discreet shipping USA order Stromectol discreet shipping USA

  283. RobertRof says:

    https://medivermonline.shop/# Stromectol ivermectin tablets for humans USA

  284. Williemaw says:

    order Stromectol discreet shipping USA: generic ivermectin online pharmacy – Stromectol ivermectin tablets for humans USA

  285. Morristic says:

    order gabapentin discreetly: NeuroCare Direct – neuropathic pain relief treatment online

  286. MichaelNix says:

    Mediverm Online ivermectin 1 how do i get ivermectin

  287. Kennetheloca says:

    https://neurocaredirect.shop/# order gabapentin discreetly

  288. RobertRof says:

    https://neurocaredirect.com/# neuropathic pain relief treatment online

  289. Williemaw says:

    order Stromectol discreet shipping USA: Stromectol ivermectin tablets for humans USA – generic ivermectin online pharmacy

  290. Morristic says:

    low-cost ivermectin for Americans: trusted Stromectol source online – Mediverm Online

  291. MichaelNix says:

    how to get Prednisone legally online online pharmacy Prednisone fast delivery how to get Prednisone legally online

  292. RobertRof says:

    https://predniwellonline.com/# online pharmacy Prednisone fast delivery

  293. Williemaw says:

    gabapentin capsules for nerve pain: Neurontin online without prescription USA – neuropathic pain relief treatment online

  294. MichaelNix says:

    generic ivermectin online pharmacy trusted Stromectol source online trusted Stromectol source online

  295. RobertRof says:

    https://medivermonline.shop/# order Stromectol discreet shipping USA

  296. Williemaw says:

    cheap 10 mg tadalafil: Tadalafil tablets – discreet delivery for ED medication

  297. Kennetheloca says:

    https://everlastrx.shop/# discreet delivery for ED medication

  298. KevinneX says:

    https://medivermonline.shop/# Stromectol ivermectin tablets for humans USA
    Mediverm Online

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *