Immanuel Church case on VAT treatment of annexes
Immanuel Church v HMRC [(2019] UKFTT 601) was a fairly routine charitable annexe case. The Church in Southbourne, Bournemouth, raised funding for an annexe/extension. In part this was to provide a secure facility for dementia sufferers and their carers. The local demographic means this is a significant issue. The project Architect sought a ruling from HMRC before construction started. HMRC insisted the work did not constitute a zero-rated annexe for VAT purposes.
Another issue arose. The Church was taking the opportunity to improve a separate part of its building which was unquestionably standard-rated. HMRC insisted that the project be treated as a single supply such that zero-rating could not be allowed unless the entire project qualified as a charitable annexe. This issue was raised in the case of Yeshivas Lubavitch Manchester (see para 20 of that decision) [a CTG commentary on this case can also be found here]. I am concerned that this appears to be a growing trend.
Correspondence continued over many months. Eventually HMRC offered an Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), which the Church Minister was keen on. Helpfully, HMRC attended the building during the period of construction. But they did not change their mind.
And so to Tribunal. I was able to bring in the Architect (and Project Manager) as a witness. He was excellent on describing the factual details of the project. I take the view that this was essential in the circumstances. The Church Minister also gave evidence, to provide a wider context in which the works were being carried out. The Tribunal commented that both were reliable witnesses.
HMRC in correspondence and in their guidance (Notice 708, para 3.2.7) suggest that an annexe should provide space for activities which are distinct from but associated with those activities being carried on in the existing building. Court and Tribunal decisions (most recently in St Brendan’s) have disapproved of this approach. I had to address this issue whilst emphasising the physical characteristics on the annexe/extension.
The only issue was whether the new structure was an annexe. HMRC had already conceded that, if the Tribunal were to find for the Church on that issue, the Note 17 tests were accepted. The Tribunal found in the taxpayer’s favour.
Les Howard is a VAT Consultant for VATadvice.org and took this case to the Tribunal
Comments
great issues altogether, you just received a
new reader. What could you recommend in regards to your post that you made a few days in the past?
Any certain? https://menbehealth.wordpress.com/
Wite more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you
relied on the video to make your point. You definitely know what youre talking about,
whyy waste your intelligence onn just posting videos to your site when you could bee
giving us somethying enlightenig to read? http://Boyarka-inform.com/
Los casinos son lugares donde los usuarios pueden disfrutar dde una amplia gama de juegbos de azar.
Entre los más populares se encuentran las tragamonedas, la ruleta, el
póker y el blackjack. Muchas personas los visitan buscanfo entretenimiento,
mientras que otros lo hacen con la esperanza dde obtener ganancias.
Hoy en día, los casinos en línea también han ganado una gran popularidad, permitiendo
a los usuarios jugar sin salir de casa. Estos ofrecen promociones atractivas
y opciones de juego variadas.
Es importante tener en cuenta que el juego debe
ser responsable y practicarse de forma controlada.
Los casinos, tanto físicos como digitales, forman parte del entretenimiento
moderno, y su éxito radica en la combinación dde suerte
y estrategia. https://fr-be.trustpilot.com/review/panacheenlignecasino.be
Welcome to Bettom a dynamic platform for online betting enthusiasts
loopking to enjoy the thrill of betting. With a diverse selection of games, Betto offers everything fropm football to eSports.
At Bettom, you’ll find competitive odds, allowing you to bet with confidence.
The site provides, a user-friendly interface makes it easy to place bets andd track yoour sports events.
Bettom also offers exclusive bonuses and promotions, including bettin rewards for new
users. Fast and safe transactions, your funds are sazfe on Bettom.uk.
Start betting at Bettom.uk and take explore alll the
exclusive deals it has to offer! https://bettom.uk/
Welcome to Bet-Tom.co.uk, a leading platform for gambling fans looking foor
the best odds. With a wide range of sports, Bet-Tom offers everything from football to horse racing.
At Bet-Tom.co.uk, players can enjoy safe annd secure betting, with easy-to-navigate features.
If you’re just starting, the platform provides clear layouts tto place bets with confidence.
Bet-Tom also provides exclusive bonuses, including free bet offers
for new users. Fast annd safe transactions, you can deposit
funds with ease.
Sign up now and take explore thhe best betting odrds on the market. https://bet-tom.co.uk/
Os depósitos são instantâneos em todos os métodos bancários e não estão sujeitos a taxas adicionais, ocupam menos espaço e ainda oferecem todos os recursos que um laptop moderno pode. Big bass splash online em modo de demonstração sem registro o Street Racer RTP é de 96,52%, você pode desfrutar de 20 modos de demonstração de slot Super Hot gratuitamente. Então vamos direto ao ponto: Pragmatic Play é uma máquina de fazer slot com esteroides, empilhando títulos insanos atrás de títulos mais insanos ainda — e tudo isso você pode testar aqui mesmo no demoslotsfun, sem pagar nada, sem se cadastrar, e com zero paciência pra burocracia. O Big Bass Bonanza tem uma taxa de RTP de 96,71%, que é acima da média para slots.
https://volleyball.psv-halle.de/index.php/2025/07/15/review-do-jogo-mines-da-spribe-explosao-de-diversao-para-jogadores-brasileiros/
“Slots há muitas, diversão sem igual só na Solverde.pt” é o mote da nova campanha do casino online português, que detém mais de 3500 jogos em simultâneo numa única plataforma. A série Fortune da PGSoft, com jogos baseados no horóscopo chinês, brilha no Blaze. Jogos como ‘Fortune Tiger’, ‘Fortune Rabbit’, ‘Fortune Ox’ e ‘Fortune Mouse’ se destacam. Eles oferecem gráficos deslumbrantes e recursos como multiplicadores e rodadas bônus. Atualmente, o Blaze Casino não possui um aplicativo para sua plataforma. Por exemplo, se você quer apostar no Blaze Casino sem precisar estudar as regras de jogos de cartas, poderá escolher um desses e simplesmente começar a jogar. Claro, respeitando os Termos e Condições da Blaze, além de qualquer regra de ofertas em que você esteja participando.
Multi-Platform Compatibility: Chicken Road is fully optimized for all devices, and you can enjoy it via the Chicken Road app without any downloads. Happiest Christmas Tree The developer does not collect any data from this app. 4RABET promotes responsible gambling at on their platform with a number of helpful resources and restrictive features. You can set loss limits on the app for a selected period by writing to support@4rabet with the exact restrictions you require. Self exclusion is also possible by contacting the support team via the app. The “Chicken Road Game” is an engaging, family-friendly video game where players assist a character, typically a chicken, in navigating across a busy road. The objective is simple but challenging: avoid obstacles and reach the other side safely. This casual game tests players’ reflexes and decision-making skills, providing endless fun and excitement.
https://daveigacoaching.com/login-to-pepeta-jet-x-and-play-like-a-local-champion/
This unblocked variant retains all the charm of the classic game but can be enjoyed anywhere, whether at school or during breaks at work. The colorful graphics and whimsical sounds add an extra layer of enjoyment for both new and seasoned players alike. Crossy Road Unblocked offers a perfect blend of challenge and fun for everyone looking for a quick gaming fix. Obstacles: Roads are filled with speeding cars, highways with trucks, rivers with floating logs, and train tracks with high-speed trains. You earn points as you merge fruits. The number of points you earn depend on the size of the fruits. Merging a pair of blueberries, for instance, is worth 1 point. You can keep track of your current score on the top right corner of the screen. Your browser saves your best score, which appears on the welcome screen just above the game’s title.
Piątkowy wieczór w Polsce jeszcze nigdy nie był tak krwawy. Gdy ktoś na imprezę zamiast chipsów przynosi maskę i kuszę, beztroska noc zmienia się w walkę o przetrwanie. Technologia zawodzi – morderca przejmuje kontrolę nad systemem bezpieczeństwa. Drzwi się zamykają, okna blokują, a dom zmienia się w więzienie. Mobilny hazard możliwy jest także za pomocą aplikacji wyprodukowanych przez kasyna online – w takim wypadku uruchomicie Spacemana w dedykowanej apce na przykład w kasynie Betmaster albo w kasynie AllRight. Apka nie jest jednak niezbędna do wpłat, wypłat i gry mobilnej. Innym rodzajem bonusu jest reload bonus, którą zalecamy sprawdzić. Programy te mają swoje zalety, jest to. Win win bet casino 50 free spins kluczową cechą Barclays blocking-tool jest to, czy te kasyna online w SC dają możliwość korzystania z funkcji uwierzytelniania dwuetapowego.
https://offside.com.ua/uncategorized/marvel-games-casino-przeglad-gier-promocji-i-ofert-bonusowych-dla-polskich-graczy/
Obstawianie gry Aviator w BanzaiBet może przynieść Ci nie tylko sporo rozrywki, ale też potencjalnie wysokie wygrane. Przy stosunkowo niskim progu wejścia i wysokim zwrocie do graczy (RTP 97,8%), crash game studia Spribe cieszy się ogromną renomą graczy. Czy istnieją jednak jakieś sprawdzone strategie BanzaiBet Aviator? Obstawianie gry Aviator w BanzaiBet może przynieść Ci nie tylko sporo rozrywki, ale też potencjalnie wysokie wygrane. Przy stosunkowo niskim progu wejścia i wysokim zwrocie do graczy (RTP 97,8%), crash game studia Spribe cieszy się ogromną renomą graczy. Czy istnieją jednak jakieś sprawdzone strategie BanzaiBet Aviator? Poza loteriami warto też sięgnąć po przygotowane przez serwis Slottica turnieje. Oferta obejmuje zarówno turnieje codzienne, jak również cotygodniowe. W ramach tych akcji hazardowych przygotowano atrakcyjne promocje, w tym głównie potężne jackpoty. Do wygrania jest bonusowa gotówka, free spiny, a także sprzęt i gadżety.
This payment is widely used as it provides secure and anonymous money transactions, NetEnt. Even the command bar under them is almost invisible, the paytable combines themed icons with playing cards from Tens to Aces. Again thank you from the bottom of my heart, slot manufacturers have invested plenty of money in making their games visually and sonically appealing – with the aim of hooking the players attention and extending their play time. Wat kost gokken jou? Stop op tijd. 18+. Loketkansspel.nl. Aviator is ideal for players who like fast games with big risks and even bigger rewards! Si vous cherchez une machine à sous amusante et unique à jouer, vous voudrez peut-être découvrir la machine à sous Lucky Ladys Charm Deluxe de Novomatic. Cette machine à sous est chargée de fonctionnalités telles que des tours gratuits et des tours de bonus, et son accessible sans enregistrement ni téléchargement. Le gameplay de base de cette fente est similaire à la plupart des autres emplacements, avec des symboles assortis pour gagner des prix en espèces.
https://drill.lovesick.jp/drilldata/index.php?kaytudema1975
Do you know what extension he\’s on? porntubereview.online egotastic Robertson has left CBN executives trying to explain his words on more than one ocassion. In May, the network released a statement attempting to clarify that Robertsonâ 11. Donny Benét – Mr. Experience Do you know what extension he\’s on? porntubereview.online egotastic Robertson has left CBN executives trying to explain his words on more than one ocassion. In May, the network released a statement attempting to clarify that Robertsonâ Flanders Literature helps publishers and festival organisers find that one particular title or author that is the perfect fit for their list or audience. So take a good look around, we present a selection of the finest literature from Flanders. If you like what you see, please get in touch with us for further information.
Bitcoin PachinkoBitcoin Pachinko combina il brivido classico del pachinko con le transazioni in Bitcoin. Nel mentre, parecchi siti annoverano le criptovalute tra i metodi di pagamento accettati. Ecco quali le cinque piattaforme più interessanti che le contemplano: Sugar Rush ti trasporta in un mondo zuccheroso pieno di leccornie. Immagina un paesaggio fatto di caramelle, lollipop e jelly beans, il tutto accompagnato da una colonna sonora allegra. La grafica accattivante e i colori vivaci rendono l’esperienza di gioco unica e immersiva. Se ami i temi dolci e divertenti, Sugar Rush sarà sicuramente di tuo gradimento. Scommesse Formula 1 BitcoinI migliori siti di scommesse online sulla Formula 1 con Bitcoin, selezionati con cura per gli appassionati di F1 in cerca dei migliori bookmaker in Bitcoin.
https://photoclub.canadiangeographic.ca/profile/21652960
I nostri servizi, l’interessante offerta di giochi e la cortese assistenza clienti vengono valutati dai nostri giocatori con 4,4 stelle nel portale di recensioni Trustpilot, ottenendo così una valutazione eccellente per i casinò svizzeri. Tra i punti di forza della nostra offerta vi sono anche l’ottimizzazione perfetta per i dispositivi mobili e le numerose modalità di pagamento. Se la nostra recensione di Sugar Twist fosse stata pubblicata prima del maggio 2023, avreste piotuto pensare che avevamo accidentalmente sbagliato titolo e giocato in realtà a Sugar Rush. Le somiglianze sono così evidenti che sembra che Pragmatic Play abbia semplicemente dato un nome diverso alla stessa slot. Mega Bonus Senza Deposito I bonus possono essere allettanti, ma leggi sempre termini e condizioni per evitare malintesi. Usali come strumento per estendere il divertimento, non come incentivo a giocare di più.
Tag @sugarfreeshops to be featured Não é apenas um estúdio, é uma casa com um estúdio. Θα βρούμε πολλές ενδιαφέρουσες θεματικές, όπως επικά παιχνίδια, κουλοχέρηδες με ταινίες ή τα καλύτερα φρουτάκια Κλεοπατρα. WhatsApp Chat is free, download and try it now here!
https://datos.olacefs.com/user/critaluncrat1977
– Το συμπαγές του σχεδιασμό, που θυμίζει ψάρι, καθιστά τον διεγέρτη βολικό για μεταφορά·- Διαθέτει αδιάβροχη επίστρωση IPX7·- Κατάλληλο για χρήση στο μπάνιο και το ντους·- Μπορεί να φορτιστεί με καλώδιο USB·- Καθαρίζεται εύκολα κάτω από τρεχούμενο νερό με καθαριστικά·- Λειτουργεί ήσυχα σε λειτουργία ψιθύρου. Εάν είστε εξοικειωμένοι με το αρχικό παιχνίδι, ξέρετε ακριβώς τι να περιμένετε, επειδή ένα από τα καλύτερα λογισμικά καζίνο δεν έχει αλλάξει τίποτα όσον αφορά το gameplay. Έτσι, έχετε έναν συνδυασμό της δυνατότητας περιστροφής και μιας αρκετά ενδιαφέρουσας δυνατότητας πολλαπλασιαστή. Αυτά τα δύο είναι τα πράγματα που σας διασκεδάζουν τόσο στη βασική όσο και στη λειτουργία μπόνους.