Implications of Brexit for charity tax
This article was first published in the September edition of Charity Finance magazine’s Brexit special.
It is now two months since the EU referendum and the UK’s decision to leave the EU. While the full implications of Brexit are still uncertain, it is possible that, whatever settlement is reached, there will be significant implications for the tax treatment of charities in the long term.
This includes both opportunities and threats; and the sector therefore needs to ensure that its voice is heard by Government during the Brexit negotiations. At the same time, until Article 50 is triggered and the exit from the EU is finalised the UK remains a full member of the EU and we carry on as at present.
VAT implications
The area of charity taxation where Brexit is likely to have most impact is VAT. VAT is a European tax, with overall policy decisions made at European level, leaving the UK Government limited scope to make unilateral policy changes. In theory, Brexit offers the Government a major opportunity to re-invent the VAT system. But will change be that radical? While the Government may ultimately consider a move to a GST-type system (though it is not at all clear why it should do so, given the administrative upheaval that a change would cause), it seems inconceivable that the UK would simply abandon the existing VAT system, at least in the short term, not least because of the revenue generated. The future structure of the VAT system in the UK is also likely be determined by the nature of the ongoing trading relationship with the EU and any concessions that may be needed to retain access to the Single Market – a consistent approach on VAT and compliance with EU State Aid rules could yet be two of them. In that connexion, it should be noted that both Iceland and Norway, though outside the EU, operate VAT regimes.
It therefore seems likely that the VAT system will largely be retained in its current form, albeit with opportunities to make significant changes at the margins. But there is the risk that the Government will wish to reduce the number of zero-rates; and many regard the current inability to reinstate zero rates once they have been withdrawn as providing additional protection to existing zero rates. Once that protection disappears, the Government may wish to target those areas that currently benefit from relief.
Sector priorities
So what are the priorities for the sector? Charities benefit from invaluable zero rates and important exemptions, yet they still face an irrecoverable VAT burden of up to £1.5bn a year. Major priorities are clearly to protect existing charity zero rates and encourage Government to consider new ones. Ironically, the European Commission’s latest Action Plan on VAT includes serious proposals to give more flexibility to Member States on VAT rates, including the prospect of new reduced and super-reduced rates.
Charities will therefore need to present strong economic arguments in favour of existing and new zero rates. Simply arguing for a “fairer” system (whatever that might mean, fairness often being in the eye of the beholder) will not be sufficient: any proposal will need to demonstrate its wider benefits to society and that it will be fiscally-neutral for the Exchequer.
Charities will wish to continue to seek significant structural reform of the VAT system, which has inherent distortions that prevent charities from operating on a level playing field with businesses and the public sector – even though this could be pushing against a resistance from Government to any radical reform. This might be in the form of much wider zero rates and super-reduced rates (possibly at the expense of exemptions); and CTG is working with its VAT Expert Group to prepare representations to the Government on behalf of the sector.
European legal judgments
Another important question relates to the status of precedents based on decisions of the CJEU. On leaving the EU, the CJEU would no longer have jurisdiction and its future decisions would not be binding on UK courts. This opens up opportunities for HMRC to clarify important principles such as the VAT business/non-business distinction, which has been clouded by inconsistent and unclear recent CJEU case law.
It seems likely, however, that if we retain any laws originating from the EU (which is probable) our courts would still take account of future CJEU judgments as persuasive, even if not binding, when ruling on those laws. At the moment, the domestic courts are required to ‘take into account’ the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights even though they are not bound by them: post-Brexit, it is not inconceivable that they could adopt the same stance in relation to the CJEU even if they were not directed to do so by statute.
It remains to be seen what other legislation originating from the EU will be removed. In response to the CJEU judgments in Persche and Stauffer, Finance Act 2010 extended UK charitable tax reliefs to eligible charitable organisations in the EU, Norway and Iceland that are equivalent to UK charities. Given that regulation of foreign charities is often far less rigorous than in the UK, HMRC had to respond by introducing the “fit and proper person” test to protect the integrity of tax relief.
However, in practice this rule has proved cumbersome and ill-targeted, with revisions to the guidance continually delayed. Evidence from HMRC suggests that very few claims for UK tax relief have been received: so, unless the UK is required to maintain “free movement of reliefs” as part of any negotiations, it is conceivable that this legislation may be repealed.
Understanding the landscape
A lot is still to be decided and at this point we can only speculate: but charities need to ensure that they identify the wider benefits of EU membership that need to be protected as well as the disbenefits that should be jettisoned. In particular, they need to identify opportunities for reform of the charity tax system in what will be a once-in-a-lifetime shift in law-making in the UK. CTG is urging all charities to undertake such an evaluation and to share their findings with the Group. This will ensure that the submissions that are made on behalf of the sector are as representative as possible.
John Hemming is Chairman of the Charity Tax Group
Comments
https://medivermonline.com/# generic ivermectin online pharmacy
Mediverm Online
trusted Stromectol source online: Stromectol ivermectin tablets for humans USA – order Stromectol discreet shipping USA
private online pharmacy UK pharmacy online UK order medication online legally in the UK
buy amoxicillin: Amoxicillin online UK – buy amoxicillin
https://medreliefuk.com/# MedRelief UK
British online pharmacy Viagra: Viagra online UK – buy viagra
buy viagra: buy sildenafil tablets UK – buy sildenafil tablets UK
http://britpharmonline.com/# buy sildenafil tablets UK
generic Amoxicillin pharmacy UK: buy penicillin alternative online – buy amoxicillin
UK online pharmacy without prescription: BritMeds Direct – UK online pharmacy without prescription
https://britmedsdirect.com/# private online pharmacy UK
MedRelief UK: buy corticosteroids without prescription UK – buy corticosteroids without prescription UK
viagra uk: British online pharmacy Viagra – BritPharm Online
buy prednisolone: UK chemist Prednisolone delivery – cheap prednisolone in UK
https://medreliefuk.shop/# MedRelief UK
UK online antibiotic service: Amoxicillin online UK – generic amoxicillin
buy corticosteroids without prescription UK: Prednisolone tablets UK online – order steroid medication safely online
http://britpharmonline.com/# buy viagra
Viagra online UK: buy viagra – British online pharmacy Viagra
generic Amoxicillin pharmacy UK: Amoxicillin online UK – cheap amoxicillin
http://amoxicareonline.com/# generic amoxicillin
Amoxicillin online UK cheap amoxicillin generic Amoxicillin pharmacy UK
amoxicillin uk: UK online antibiotic service – generic Amoxicillin pharmacy UK
Amoxicillin online UK: generic Amoxicillin pharmacy UK – buy amoxicillin
https://britmedsdirect.shop/# private online pharmacy UK
cheap prednisolone in UK cheap prednisolone in UK order steroid medication safely online
viagra: viagra uk – order ED pills online UK
https://amoxicareonline.com/# generic amoxicillin
viagra British online pharmacy Viagra BritPharm Online
mexican pharmacy: mexican pharmacy – mexican pharmacy
https://tadalifepharmacy.shop/# Cialis online USA
affordable Cialis with fast delivery: trusted online pharmacy for ED meds – tadalafil tablets without prescription
MedicoSur mexican pharmacy MedicoSur
safe online medication store: order medicine discreetly USA – buy clomid
http://tadalifepharmacy.com/# Cialis online USA
https://zencaremeds.shop/# order medicine discreetly USA
online pharmacy: buy Doxycycline – online pharmacy
ZenCare Meds com buy clomid buy amoxil
https://tadalifepharmacy.shop/# generic Cialis online pharmacy
safe online medication store: online pharmacy – buy amoxil
MedicoSur mexican pharmacies that ship to us mexican pharmacy
https://medicosur.com/# MedicoSur
https://tadalifepharmacy.com/# trusted online pharmacy for ED meds
TadaLife Pharmacy: tadalafil tablets without prescription – generic Cialis online pharmacy
ZenCare Meds trusted online pharmacy USA online pharmacy
https://tadalifepharmacy.shop/# affordable Cialis with fast delivery
buying prescription drugs in mexico: mexico pharmacy – mexican pharmacy
mexican pharmacy: mexico pharmacy – mexican rx pharm
http://tadalifepharmacy.com/# buy cialis online
http://zencaremeds.com/# canadian pharmacy sildenafil
buy Doxycycline: buy propecia – ZenCare Meds com
cialis TadaLife Pharmacy safe online pharmacy for Cialis
https://medicosur.shop/# farmacias online usa
ZenCareMeds: ZenCareMeds – canadian pharmacy 24h com
buy Doxycycline: buy propecia – trusted online pharmacy USA
https://tadalifepharmacy.com/# discreet ED pills delivery in the US
safe online medication store affordable online pharmacy for Americans buy amoxil
https://zencaremeds.shop/# ZenCare Meds com
mexico pharmacy: mexican pharmacy – mexico pharmacy
tadalafil senza ricetta farmacie online autorizzate elenco farmacia online italiana Cialis
Intimi Santé: acheter Cialis en ligne France – cialis prix
https://tadalafiloexpress.com/# cialis precio
https://potenzvital.com/# potenzmittel cialis
cialis kaufen cialis 20mg preis cialis kaufen
tadalafil italiano approvato AIFA: cialis generico – PilloleVerdi
https://pilloleverdi.com/# tadalafil senza ricetta
miglior prezzo Cialis originale farmacia online senza ricetta tadalafil senza ricetta
cialis 20 mg achat en ligne: cialis sans ordonnance – achat discret de Cialis 20mg
PotenzVital: tadalafil 20 mg preis – Cialis Preisvergleich Deutschland
https://tadalafiloexpress.shop/# tadalafilo
http://potenzvital.com/# internet apotheke
tadalafilo tadalafilo sin receta comprar cialis
IntimiSanté: cialis generique – Pharmacie Internationale en ligne
acquistare Cialis online Italia cialis miglior prezzo Cialis originale
https://intimisante.shop/# acheter Cialis en ligne France
cialis: farmacie online autorizzate elenco – farmacia online italiana Cialis
http://intimisante.com/# livraison rapide et confidentielle
Intimi Santé pharmacie en ligne fiable Cialis générique pas cher
http://intimisante.com/# achat discret de Cialis 20mg
tadalafilo sin receta: tadalafilo 5 mg precio – tadalafilo 5 mg precio
tadalafilo sin receta farmacia online fiable en España Tadalafilo Express
https://intimisante.shop/# IntimiSante
Tadalafil 20mg Bestellung online: PotenzVital – Cialis generika günstig kaufen
https://intimisante.shop/# pharmacie qui vend du cialis sans ordonnance
cialis kaufen ohne rezept cialis 20mg preis cialis generika
Tadalafil 20mg Bestellung online: cialis generika – Cialis Preisvergleich Deutschland
https://intimisante.com/# cialis sans ordonnance
comprar Cialis online España cialis generico cialis generico
cialis precio: farmacia online fiable en España – farmacia online fiable en España
https://tadalafiloexpress.shop/# farmacias online seguras en espaГ±a
http://potenzvital.com/# tadalafil 20 mg preis
Potenz Vital Cialis Preisvergleich Deutschland cialis generika
tadalafilo 5 mg precio: farmacia online espaГ±a envГo internacional – comprar Cialis online España
http://potenzvital.com/# cialis generika
dove comprare Cialis in Italia cialis prezzo PilloleVerdi
Sildenafil 100 mg bestellen: Sildenafil ohne Rezept – Viagra kaufen gГјnstig Deutschland
http://medivertraut.com/# Potenzmittel rezeptfrei kaufen
https://medivertraut.shop/# Sildenafil Wirkung und Dosierung
difference between Viagra and generic Sildenafil difference between Viagra and generic Sildenafil Blue Peak Meds
Viagra online UK: trusted British pharmacy – licensed online pharmacy UK
https://britmedsuk.shop/# trusted British pharmacy
Sildenafil side effects and safe dosage Blue Peak Meds difference between Viagra and generic Sildenafil
sichere Online-Apotheke Deutschland: Sildenafil Wirkung und Dosierung – Medi Vertraut
https://medivertraut.shop/# п»їViagra kaufen
https://bluepeakmeds.shop/# Sildenafil online reviews
sildenafil 50 mg price: Sildenafil side effects and safe dosage – how generic Viagra works in the body
https://santehommefrance.com/# Viagra homme sans ordonnance belgique
Sildenafil 50mg licensed online pharmacy UK trusted British pharmacy
Sildenafil 100mg price: sildenafil over the counter – Blue Peak Meds
https://medivertraut.com/# Potenzmittel rezeptfrei kaufen
https://medivertraut.shop/# sichere Online-Apotheke Deutschland
cheapest viagra difference between Viagra and generic Sildenafil Blue Peak Meds
SanteHommeFrance: sildenafil 50 mg ou 100 mg posologie – Viagra générique pas cher
Viagra Generika 100mg rezeptfrei: MediVertraut – Medi Vertraut
https://mediuomo.com/# trattamento ED online Italia
MannensApotek mannens apotek MannensApotek
HerenGezondheid: goedkope Viagra tabletten online – Viagra online kopen Nederland
http://mannensapotek.com/# mannens apotek
https://mediuomo.shop/# miglior sito per acquistare Sildenafil online
mannens apotek Sildenafil utan recept erektionspiller på nätet
online apotheek zonder recept: Heren Gezondheid – HerenGezondheid
https://mediuomo.com/# Viagra generico con pagamento sicuro
miglior sito per acquistare Sildenafil online Viagra generico con pagamento sicuro pillole per disfunzione erettile
Sildenafil utan recept: apotek online utan recept – Viagra utan läkarbesök
https://mediuomo.shop/# farmaci per potenza maschile
https://confiafarmacia.shop/# Viagra generico online Espana
veilige online medicijnen Nederland erectiepillen discreet bestellen ED-medicatie zonder voorschrift
MannensApotek: diskret leverans i Sverige – Sildenafil-tabletter pris
http://mannensapotek.com/# kopa Viagra online Sverige
Sildenafil zonder recept bestellen: Heren Gezondheid – Viagra online kopen Nederland
pillole per disfunzione erettile Viagra generico online Italia MediUomo
https://confiafarmacia.com/# Viagra generico online Espana
http://confiafarmacia.com/# Viagra sin prescripcion medica
mannens apotek: mannens apotek – erektionspiller på nätet
Viagra sin prescripción médica ConfiaFarmacia farmacia con entrega rápida
https://mediuomo.com/# Viagra generico con pagamento sicuro
onlineapotek för män: köp receptfria potensmedel online – köpa Viagra online Sverige
Confia Farmacia Viagra genérico online España farmacia confiable en España
https://mediuomo.com/# Viagra generico con pagamento sicuro
https://mediuomo.com/# MediUomo
erektionspiller på nätet: onlineapotek för män – diskret leverans i Sverige
pastillas de potencia masculinas pastillas de potencia masculinas Confia Farmacia
online apotheek zonder recept: online apotheek zonder recept – HerenGezondheid
https://mediuomo.com/# trattamento ED online Italia
MediUomo: Viagra generico online Italia – trattamento ED online Italia
goedkope Viagra tabletten online erectiepillen discreet bestellen veilige online medicijnen Nederland
onlineapotek för män: erektionspiller på nätet – mannens apotek
https://mediuomo.com/# pillole per disfunzione erettile
http://herengezondheid.com/# erectiepillen discreet bestellen
farmacia con entrega rápida farmacia con entrega rápida ConfiaFarmacia
köpa Viagra online Sverige: köp receptfria potensmedel online – Sildenafil utan recept
Viagra utan läkarbesök: Sildenafil utan recept – onlineapotek för män
https://confiafarmacia.shop/# Viagra sin prescripcion medica
Mann Vital viagra reseptfri ereksjonspiller på nett
kamagra: Kamagra sans ordonnance – kamagra
https://vitahomme.com/# Vita Homme
https://vitahomme.shop/# Kamagra sans ordonnance
Sildenafil tabletter pris Mann Vital Mann Vital
Avanafil senza ricetta: acquistare Spedra online – FarmaciaViva
https://vitahomme.com/# Sildenafil generique
kamagra: VitaHomme – Kamagra sans ordonnance
http://farmaciavivait.com/# Spedra
Kamagra online kaufen: Erfahrungen mit Kamagra 100mg – Kamagra 100mg bestellen
Kamagra Oral Jelly Deutschland: Kamagra Wirkung und Nebenwirkungen – diskrete Lieferung per DHL
comprare medicinali online legali: differenza tra Spedra e Viagra – farmacia viva
kamagra oral jelly: Kamagra 100mg prix France – VitaHomme
Potenzmittel ohne ärztliches Rezept: vital pharma 24 – Kamagra online kaufen
http://vitahomme.com/# Kamagra 100mg prix France
kamagra oral jelly: Kamagra sans ordonnance – Kamagra 100mg prix France
Erfahrungen mit Kamagra 100mg: Kamagra Oral Jelly Deutschland – Kamagra online kaufen
acheter Kamagra en ligne: Kamagra livraison rapide en France – Kamagra sans ordonnance
Spedra prezzo basso Italia: differenza tra Spedra e Viagra – Avanafil senza ricetta
kamagra: kamagra – Kamagra sans ordonnance
https://farmaciavivait.com/# differenza tra Spedra e Viagra
diskrete Lieferung per DHL: Kamagra Oral Jelly Deutschland – Kamagra Oral Jelly Deutschland
Avanafil senza ricetta: comprare medicinali online legali – farmacia viva
vitalpharma24: Erfahrungen mit Kamagra 100mg – Erfahrungen mit Kamagra 100mg
Kamagra Oral Jelly Deutschland: vital pharma 24 – vitalpharma24
differenza tra Spedra e Viagra: Spedra prezzo basso Italia – comprare medicinali online legali
acheter Kamagra en ligne: VitaHomme – Kamagra pas cher France
Erfahrungen mit Kamagra 100mg: vitalpharma24 – Kamagra Oral Jelly Deutschland
https://mannvital.com/# Sildenafil uten resept
acquistare Spedra online: comprare medicinali online legali – Spedra
kamagra: Kamagra sans ordonnance – VitaHomme
diskrete Lieferung per DHL: Kamagra online kaufen – vital pharma 24
comprare medicinali online legali: comprare medicinali online legali – farmacia viva
Kamagra 100mg prix France: acheter Kamagra en ligne – Kamagra livraison rapide en France
differenza tra Spedra e Viagra: differenza tra Spedra e Viagra – farmacia viva
vital pharma 24: diskrete Lieferung per DHL – Kamagra Oral Jelly Deutschland
https://mannvital.com/# MannVital
farmacia viva: acquistare Spedra online – Spedra prezzo basso Italia
kamagra: Kamagra livraison rapide en France – Kamagra livraison rapide en France
billig Viagra Norge: Sildenafil tabletter pris – viagra reseptfri
Irish Pharma Finder
discount pharmacies in Ireland discount pharmacies in Ireland discount pharmacies in Ireland
buy medicine online legally Ireland: pharmacy delivery Ireland – buy medicine online legally Ireland
online pharmacy: best pharmacy sites with discounts – compare online pharmacy prices
online pharmacy ireland
http://aussiemedshubau.com/# cheap medicines online Australia
cheap medicines online UK Uk Meds Guide UK online pharmacies list
best Irish pharmacy websites: affordable medication Ireland – buy medicine online legally Ireland
pharmacy delivery Ireland: affordable medication Ireland – irishpharmafinder
trusted online pharmacy Ireland
Irish Pharma Finder discount pharmacies in Ireland online pharmacy
online pharmacy: trusted online pharmacy Ireland – Irish Pharma Finder
http://irishpharmafinder.com/# pharmacy delivery Ireland
online pharmacy ireland
best online pharmacy online pharmacy reviews and ratings best online pharmacy
buy medicine online legally Ireland: irishpharmafinder – online pharmacy
Safe Meds Guide: best online pharmacy – compare online pharmacy prices
trusted online pharmacy Ireland
cheap medicines online UK: cheap medicines online UK – affordable medications UK
Irish Pharma Finder online pharmacy ireland top-rated pharmacies in Ireland
online pharmacy reviews and ratings: online pharmacy – best pharmacy sites with discounts
http://safemedsguide.com/# online pharmacy
top-rated pharmacies in Ireland
cheapest pharmacies in the USA: SafeMedsGuide – trusted online pharmacy USA
online pharmacy top rated online pharmacies best online pharmacy
buy medications online safely: online pharmacy – buy medications online safely
UkMedsGuide: legitimate pharmacy sites UK – legitimate pharmacy sites UK
affordable medication Ireland
promo codes for online drugstores best pharmacy sites with discounts best pharmacy sites with discounts
trusted online pharmacy UK: UK online pharmacies list – cheap medicines online UK
UkMedsGuide: online pharmacy – online pharmacy
buy medicine online legally Ireland
https://aussiemedshubau.com/# pharmacy online
Safe Meds Guide: best online pharmacy – top rated online pharmacies
UK online pharmacies list affordable medications UK trusted online pharmacy UK
Aussie Meds Hub: AussieMedsHubAu – trusted online pharmacy Australia
trusted online pharmacy USA: promo codes for online drugstores – SafeMedsGuide
compare online pharmacy prices promo codes for online drugstores best pharmacy sites with discounts
online pharmacy: Irish online pharmacy reviews – top-rated pharmacies in Ireland
discount pharmacies in Ireland
Uk Meds Guide: safe place to order meds UK – online pharmacy
UkMedsGuide UkMedsGuide trusted online pharmacy UK
https://ukmedsguide.shop/# best UK pharmacy websites
Australian pharmacy reviews: trusted online pharmacy Australia – AussieMedsHubAu
Irish Pharma Finder
promo codes for online drugstores: cheapest pharmacies in the USA – Safe Meds Guide
compare pharmacy websites: Australian pharmacy reviews – Aussie Meds Hub Australia
top-rated pharmacies in Ireland
buy medications online safely: best online pharmacy – Safe Meds Guide
buy medications online safely online pharmacy reviews and ratings cheapest pharmacies in the USA
https://aussiemedshubau.shop/# pharmacy online
Irish online pharmacy reviews: discount pharmacies in Ireland – irishpharmafinder
pharmacy delivery Ireland
safe place to order meds UK: online pharmacy – online pharmacy
trusted online pharmacy Australia online pharmacy australia best Australian pharmacies
online pharmacy ireland: pharmacy delivery Ireland – Irish online pharmacy reviews
irishpharmafinder
trusted online pharmacy Australia: verified online chemists in Australia – pharmacy discount codes AU
online pharmacy buy medications online safely best online pharmacy
best Australian pharmacies: verified online chemists in Australia – verified online chemists in Australia