Off-payroll working will be a major change for larger charities when it is introduced in April 2020. It will mean that those charities will have new responsibilities to pay PAYE and national insurance (and apprenticeship levy where appropriate) where a personal service company is engaged…
This reflects changes already applying in the public sector. It may seem a long way off but there are issues that need to be thought about now. The purpose of this article is to set out what charity finance professionals need to be thinking about now.
Is your charity subject to the new rules?
Only charities which meet the Companies Act definitions of a medium or large company have to comply. Companies which are “small” need not comply. For this to apply, two out of three criteria must be met.
1) Less than 50 employees
2) Total assets of less than £5.1m
3) Turnover of less than £10.2m.
The uncertainty here is what is the turnover of a charity? For other tax issues the charity sector has agreed with HMRC that this test should be applied in a strict way. Turnover is simply income from the sale of goods and services. As a result, donations and grant income are excluded. But it might well be that this will not apply here and that total income of a charity will be the measure that HMRC apply. HMRC are currently considering this issue but at the time of writing have not come to a final decision.
The vast majority of charities will be small, but many will not. So, if you are caught what will the new rules mean in practice?
When utilising a personal service company (a company by which a contactor provides his or her services to a ‘client’ such as a charity) a charity will have to consider whether those services would be an employment but for the use of that company. If it does, then the company becomes a deemed ‘employee’ and PAYE and national insurance contributions need to be paid. Other personal service companies can be treated as they are currently.
Importantly, this change will not create an employee relationship. The person operating the personal service company will not have employee rights such as holiday pay and sick pay. But it could be a sensitive issue with individuals who are used to having payments made to their company gross. These individuals will need to be managed sensitively and it would certainly be unwise to leave these discussions until the last minute.
This is particularly so as HMRC are introducing the changes as the owners of many personal service companies do not comply properly with the current “IR35 rules”. These rules require such companies to pay over tax and national insurance on a similar basis to what would be paid in respect of an employee delivering the same services. This leads to a tax shortfall. HMRC estimate that only 10% apply the current IR35 rules properly.
This then leads to a question of how the level of payment to personal service companies caught by the new rules should be pitched?
If employer’s national insurance will need to be paid, then these services will suddenly become 13.8% more expensive. A cost that many charities cannot afford. This is important when entering into new arrangements with personal service companies. Do the right people in your charity know about this and what are the implications of existing contractual terms included in the agreement with the personal service company?
Then there are the practical implementation issues to think about
It would be wise to get in touch with your payroll system provider. What are they doing to ensure that your systems will be ready for the change and how do they expect this to operate? A further complication is that the personal service company is likely to continue issuing invoices as it has before. These will generally include VAT.
So, changes will be required to your accounts payable systems which will presumably pay the VAT whilst the net value of the invoice will, in effect, be processed by your payroll system. How will this work? You will most probably need to speak to the systems provider for your accounts payable system – assuming that you do not have some form of integrated package.
So, there is much to think about. My plea is simply that we all make the most of the time given to us to plan for the impact of off payroll working. As we all know the implementation date will be with us sooner than we think.
Richard Bray is Vice-Chairman of the Charity Tax Group and produced this article for Charity Financials as part of a new regular series of updates.
Members are reminded that HMRC is consulting on the extension of off-payroll working rules to the private sector. The deadline for responses is 29 May 2019.
The consultation asks for views and information on a number subjects, including:
- the scope of the reform and impact on non-corporate engagers
- information requirements for engagers, fee-payers and personal service companies
- addressing status determination disagreements
The consultation also sets out how businesses can prepare for reform, and sets out HMRC’s plans to provide education and support for businesses that will be in scope of the changes.