Payroll Services provided by Charities
Charities sometimes provide payroll services to persons with disabilities, to allow these people to employ, and remunerate, a carer. The provision of care services by a charity would be exempt from VAT. Where the only service provided is of running the payroll service, the charity will argue that that service is exempt, owing to the special needs of the service recipient and that person’s incapacity to deal with the arrangements for employing the carer.
Following an unsatisfactory piece of litigation, HMRC has issued R&C Brief 16(2020) which confirms their view that these services are taxable, and not exempt. The litigation was unsatisfactory in the sense that the appellant, Cheshire Centre for Independent Living, won its case at the First tier Tribunal, but withdrew from the appeal to the Upper Tribunal. Since it withdrew, the Tribunal had no choice but the allow HMRC’s appeal against the First tier decision, and the result is that this decision is regarded as null and void. A further complication was that the First tier Tribunal inferred that HMRC accepted that the service was ancillary to an exempt service of care, whereas the fact was that the service of the carer was provided as an employee and therefore not a service (for VAT purposes) at all. This arcane distinction was thus being advanced by HMRC, on its appeal, and was the apparent reason that the charity decided not to contest the appeal.
The Brief invites those charities that have appeals stood behind this litigation to consider whether to pursue their own litigation, or to now give up the fight.
The arguments are both technical and arcane in the extreme. The concept that a payroll service for such persons is analogous to running of a simple payroll for convenience’ sake is far-fetched. However, it is clearly more an enabling service than one of direct care, so the issue appears to be whether it is sufficiently integral and necessary to the needs of the user to create a form of care notwithstanding this. All the Brief says is that such a service must be “‘logically part of, or an indispensable stage’ in the provision of the general care and domestic help provided to the disabled person.” It is difficult to see how provision of a payment service for a person who lacks the ability to carry out that service is not an “indispensable stage” in that domestic help and care.
However, it now falls to other charities to determine whether to take this forward in the face of HMRC’s desire to interpret the rules in the most taxing way they can.
Comments
https://biotpharm.com/# best online doctor for antibiotics
buy antibiotics from india: buy antibiotics online – best online doctor for antibiotics
Licensed online pharmacy AU Online drugstore Australia Online drugstore Australia
antibiotic without presription buy antibiotics online buy antibiotics over the counter
Over the counter antibiotics for infection: Biot Pharm – best online doctor for antibiotics
https://pharmau24.com/# Discount pharmacy Australia
online ed meds cheapest online ed treatment ed medicines online
buy antibiotics from india: buy antibiotics online uk – Over the counter antibiotics for infection
online ed treatments: cheapest ed medication – Ero Pharm Fast
https://biotpharm.com/# buy antibiotics from india
cheap ed medication Ero Pharm Fast cheap ed pills online
buy antibiotics for uti: buy antibiotics online – buy antibiotics over the counter
online pharmacy australia Online drugstore Australia Pharm Au 24
http://eropharmfast.com/# ed pills
Ero Pharm Fast Ero Pharm Fast Ero Pharm Fast
online pharmacy australia Pharm Au24 Pharm Au24
https://eropharmfast.com/# cheapest online ed treatment
commander sans consultation médicale: pharmacie en ligne sans prescription – pharmacie en ligne pas cher
pharmacie en ligne fiable cialis generique cialis sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne pas cher: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie en ligne france pas cher
kamagra pas cher: kamagra 100mg prix – acheter kamagra site fiable
Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance Viagra generique en pharmacie Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h
acheter Viagra sans ordonnance: commander Viagra discretement – Viagra pas cher inde
http://pharmsansordonnance.com/# pharmacie en ligne france pas cher
pharmacie en ligne sans prescription: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe
acheter Cialis sans ordonnance cialis sans ordonnance Cialis sans ordonnance 24h
acheter Viagra sans ordonnance: acheter Viagra sans ordonnance – Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne fiable: acheter Cialis sans ordonnance – acheter Cialis sans ordonnance
commander sans consultation medicale Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable
https://ciasansordonnance.com/# traitement ED discret en ligne
kamagra gel: achat kamagra – livraison discrète Kamagra
acheter medicaments sans ordonnance: acheter medicaments sans ordonnance – vente de mГ©dicament en ligne
pharmacie en ligne Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h pharmacie en ligne fiable
Cialis sans ordonnance 24h: acheter Cialis sans ordonnance – Cialis pas cher livraison rapide
achat kamagra: kamagra en ligne – kamagra pas cher
acheter medicaments sans ordonnance acheter medicaments sans ordonnance acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
https://pharmsansordonnance.shop/# pharmacie en ligne france pas cher
livraison discrète Kamagra: kamagra oral jelly – commander Kamagra en ligne
kamagra livraison 24h acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance kamagra livraison 24h
pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance: Pharmacies en ligne certifiées – Pharmacie Internationale en ligne
cialis generique: Acheter Cialis – cialis sans ordonnance
https://kampascher.com/# acheter kamagra site fiable
cialis sans ordonnance: cialis prix – Cialis pas cher livraison rapide
Viagra generique en pharmacie Viagra generique en pharmacie commander Viagra discretement
pharmacie en ligne pas cher: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – Pharmacie sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: commander sans consultation médicale – pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne sans prescription pharmacie internet fiable France pharmacie en ligne fiable
https://kampascher.com/# kamagra livraison 24h
commander Cialis en ligne sans prescription: cialis sans ordonnance – Cialis sans ordonnance 24h
cialis prix: cialis sans ordonnance – traitement ED discret en ligne
kamagra en ligne achat kamagra kamagra pas cher
acheter Cialis sans ordonnance: cialis sans ordonnance – Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher
achat kamagra: commander Kamagra en ligne – kamagra 100mg prix
Cialis sans ordonnance 24h commander Cialis en ligne sans prescription Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher
https://pharmsansordonnance.shop/# pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es
acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance acheter kamagra site fiable acheter kamagra site fiable
acheter Viagra sans ordonnance: viagra en ligne – Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h
viagra sans ordonnance acheter Viagra sans ordonnance livraison rapide Viagra en France
http://kampascher.com/# Kamagra oral jelly pas cher
prix bas Viagra generique: livraison rapide Viagra en France – Viagra pas cher livraison rapide france
Cialis generique sans ordonnance Cialis generique sans ordonnance Cialis generique sans ordonnance
Viagra sans ordonnance 24h: viagra en ligne – viagra en ligne
Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h Viagra vente libre pays Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance
acheter Cialis sans ordonnance Acheter Cialis commander Cialis en ligne sans prescription
acheter medicaments sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne france pas cher – trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie
https://kampascher.com/# kamagra oral jelly
acheter Viagra sans ordonnance Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance viagra en ligne
Cialis generique sans ordonnance cialis sans ordonnance Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher
http://ciasansordonnance.com/# Cialis sans ordonnance 24h
prix bas Viagra generique Viagra generique en pharmacie viagra en ligne
commander sans consultation medicale Pharmacies en ligne certifiees pharmacie en ligne fiable
livraison rapide Viagra en France: acheter Viagra sans ordonnance – Viagra sans ordonnance 24h
kamagra gel acheter kamagra site fiable commander Kamagra en ligne
http://ciasansordonnance.com/# traitement ED discret en ligne
pharmacie en ligne pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h viagra sans ordonnance livraison rapide Viagra en France
clobesol pomata prezzo: clasteon 100 mg fiale prezzo – en gocce
creme pour bander en pharmacie sans ordonnance som actif sommeil posologie peut on acheter alli en pharmacie sans ordonnance
comprar sintrom sin receta: naltrexona comprar sin receta – comprar vardenafilo sin receta
gingembre et foie: peut on se rendre dans une pharmacie de garde sans ordonnance – test infection urinaire pharmacie sans ordonnance
gramplus supposte bambini raffreddore farmacia online veterinaria monuril online
http://confiapharma.com/# comprar sumial 10 sin receta
ordonnance cialis: somnif̬re puissant sans ordonnance en pharmacie Рkamagra en pharmacie sans ordonnance
peut on aller chez le cardiologue sans ordonnance ivermectine crГЁme sans ordonnance medicament erection sans ordonnance
medecin en ligne pour ordonnance: Pharmacie Express – slim ventre plat
farmacia online test rapido covid: shop farmacia online italia – comprar medicamentos online sin receta
http://farmaciasubito.com/# biorinil spray prezzo
ivermectina se puede comprar sin receta Confia Pharma oxГmetro farmacia online
infection urinaire femme medicament sans ordonnance: Pharmacie Express – sildenafil 100mg 24 comprimГ©s (viagraВ® gГ©nГ©rique) prix
cr̬me zensa pharmacie sans ordonnance: generique daflon Рtredemine sans ordonnance
amoxicilina comprar sin receta curso auxiliar de farmacia online homologado farmacia online en canarias
https://pharmacieexpress.com/# tubertest pharmacie sans ordonnance
clody 200 fiale parvati principio attivo indom collirio monodose
vardenafil 20mg: antistaminico pafinur – sonirem principio attivo
comprar testogel sin receta comprar en una farmacia online castro farmacia online
sonirem principio attivo: Farmacia Subito – sofacor collirio a cosa serve
epithelial creme combien dure une ordonnance peut on se faire tester en pharmacie sans ordonnance
https://pharmacieexpress.com/# gГ©nГ©rique viagra homme
desloratadine ordonnance ou pas: mГ©dicament pour infection urinaire sans ordonnance – coquelusedal sur ordonnance ou pas
xanax 0 5 rilascio prolungato di base gocce prezzo augmentin sciroppo bambini 70 ml
shop online farmacia: lansox 15 mg compresse orodispersibili prezzo – exinef 90 mg prezzo
tadalafil 20 mg prix en pharmacie Pharmacie Express trod angine pharmacie sans ordonnance
https://confiapharma.shop/# furosemida comprar sin receta
farmacia conveniente online: xanax gocce prezzo – zolpeduar a cosa serve
farmacia via filippo di giovanni palermo motilium prezzo farmacia consegna a domicilio vicino a me
farmacia online gratis: donde puedo comprar medicamentos sin receta – comprar enalapril sin receta
https://confiapharma.com/# zolpidem se puede comprar sin receta
pharmacie avec ordonnance en ligne: vitamine d en gouttes en pharmacie sans ordonnance – somnifГЁre sans ordonnance pharmacie
se puede comprar mupirocina sin receta: buste farmacia vendita online – farmacia online klarna
farmacia para perros online: donde comprar clamoxyl sin receta – donde comprar fentermina sin receta
puedo comprar clindamicina sin receta farmacia segura para comprar online puedo comprar codeina sin receta
comprar medicina lombrices sin receta: eroxon se puede comprar sin receta – comprar testosterona inyectable sin receta
m̩dicament contre le stress sans ordonnance: viagra homme prix Рcialis 20 mg prix
trova farmaco farmacia online francia sconti farmacia online
entact 10 mg prezzo: Farmacia Subito – online farmacia italia
http://farmaciasubito.com/# farmacia iglio airola
creme epilatoire vichy: ordonnance aide Г domicile – tramadol sans ordonnance suisse
donde comprar quetiapina sin receta Confia Pharma se puede comprar clindamicina sin receta
si puГІ dare il bentelan al cane: farmacia online consegna 24h – felison principio attivo
geniad gocce vitamina d: metformina 500 prezzo – bimadoc collirio prezzo
test diabГЁte pharmacie sans ordonnance: daflon 500 sans ordonnance prix – viagra homme prix en pharmacie sans ordonnance
https://farmaciasubito.shop/# inneov densilogy
donde comprar viagra sin receta en murcia: Confia Pharma – farmacia en tenerife online
como comprar prednisona 30 mg sin receta medica: farmacia online talavera dela reina – comprar orlistat 120 mg sin receta
farmacia san tomio verona: Farmacia Subito – egerian crema
testoviron prezzo cortivis collirio clobesol crema prezzo farmacia
pharmacy support viagra pharmacy cialis generic nexium pharmacy price
mexican pharma: mexican online pharmacy – semaglutide mexican pharmacy
https://pharmexpress24.shop/# online pharmacy sildenafil 100mg
https://pharmexpress24.shop/# pharmacy store window
tramadol mexico best pharmacy in mexico medicines mexico review
cialis super active online pharmacy: community rx pharmacy – mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
mexican pharmacy delivery: hydroxychloroquine mexican pharmacy – mexican pharmacy products
clozaril pharmacy: norvasc online pharmacy – big online pharmacy
nizoral shampoo uk pharmacy cialis internet pharmacy cymbalta pharmacy prices
https://pharmexpress24.com/# wegmans pharmacy free atorvastatin
mexico pharmacy price list ozempic: can i buy ozempic in mexico? – online drugstore usa
pharmacy website in india: InPharm24 – pharmacy india
mexican pharmacy cytomel: your pharmacy online – farmacias online mexico
tadalafil online us pharmacy people’s pharmacy zoloft empower rx pharmacy
pharmacy in india online: buy medicine online in india – pharmacy india website
kroger pharmacy tamiflu: indian pharmacy strattera – Aebgkeymn
Tofranil: creighton university pharmacy online – pharmacy cost of percocet
https://inpharm24.shop/# pharmacy online india
what drugs can you buy in mexico drugs from mexico to us can you get oxycodone in mexico
india online pharmacy: InPharm24 – medplus pharmacy india
bupropion pharmacy prices: dostinex online pharmacy – bm pharmacy accutane
reliable pharmacy india: InPharm24 – pharmacy india website
which pharmacy has tamiflu dutasteride online pharmacy georgia board of pharmacy
aster pharmacy india: first online pharmacy in india – top online pharmacy in india
mexican pharmacy nuevo laredo: Pharm Mex – otc drugs in mexico
http://inpharm24.com/# b pharmacy salary in india
how to buy ozempic in mexico: Pharm Mex – international pharmacies
buy medicine from india prescriptions from india best online pharmacy in india
amoxicillin mexico over the counter: can you order prescriptions online – mexican veterinary pharmacy online
doxycycline mexican pharmacy: us based online pharmacy – first medicine online pharmacy store discount code
rite aid pharmacy viagra: Pharm Express 24 – dapoxetine uk pharmacy
express rx pharmacy los angeles access pharmacy viagra mexico pharmacy viagra
us online pharmacy viagra: india pharmacy – freds pharmacy store
http://pharmexpress24.com/# pharmacy customer care viagra
rx clinic pharmacy: Pharm Express 24 – best online ambien pharmacy
can i order penicillin online mexico online pharmacy tretinoin cream mexican pharmacy
top rated online pharmacy: donepezil online pharmacy – thyroxine pharmacy
u s a online pharmacy: adipex pharmacy prices – viagra discount pharmacy
best pharmacy in india: india mail order pharmacy – cialis india pharmacy
can you buy vyvanse over the counter in mexico Pharm Mex is mexican viagra safe
mexican tramadol: Pharm Mex – mexican pharmacy cancun
mexican rx: mexican pharmacy ritalin – nogales mexico pharmacy
http://inpharm24.com/# india online pharmacy
wellbutrin pharmacy online: proventil online pharmacy – inhouse pharmacy depo provera
codeine in mexico prescription free online pharmacy tijuana pharmacy near border
ozempic purchase in mexico: mexican prednisone – klonopin mexico
buying medication in mexico Pharm Mex mexican pharmacy retin a
india online medicine: InPharm24 – career after b pharmacy in india
bupropion online pharmacy: advair pharmacy price – cost of cialis at pharmacy
viagra over the counter VGR Sources sildenafil 50 mg tablet price in india
30 mg sildenafil buy online: VGR Sources – where can you purchase female viagra
female viagra tablet price: viagra prescription cost – where to purchase viagra pills
how to buy over the counter viagra: viagra over the counter cost – online sildenafil without prescription
https://vgrsources.com/# purchase female viagra
viagra 100 cost VGR Sources viagra europe pharmacy
generic viagra 50: order viagra cheap online – sildenafil price in usa
cheap generic viagra in canada: VGR Sources – brand viagra 50 mg
viagra daily: VGR Sources – brand viagra
average cost of viagra 100mg: lowest price sildenafil – generic viagra 100mg india
can you buy female viagra sildenafil 100mg sale best generic sildenafil
female viagra real: VGR Sources – canada viagra online
can you buy viagra over the counter australia: viagra online india buy – canadian pharmacy online viagra
https://vgrsources.com/# can you buy viagra in canada
sildenafil over the counter australia: buy sildenafil online usa – real viagra pills online
viagra on line VGR Sources viagra pills online india
viagra tablet online india: can you buy viagra in canada – brand viagra online
drugstore viagra: sildenafil 100 mg uk – viagra 200mg price
can you buy generic viagra: best online sildenafil – sildenafil 25 mg india
viagra for sale in australia: viagra pills price in india – 415 viagra 4
order sildenafil VGR Sources over the counter viagra online
https://vgrsources.com/# canada viagra cost
sildenafil 50 coupon: cheap generic viagra for sale – viagra 100mg prices
viagra professional online: sildenafil 50 mg tablet buy online – brand name viagra for sale
indian viagra: sildenafil canada over the counter – what does viagra do
viagra usa viagra for female for sale online sildenafil canada
sildenafil online prices: cheap viagra india online – buy viagra 500mg
generic viagra order: 1 viagra pill – viagra prescription uk
where to order generic viagra: VGR Sources – buy sildenafil with paypal
sildenafil 25 mg mexico sildenafil online purchase india viagra for women sale
https://vgrsources.com/# i want to buy viagra
uk viagra buy: 200mg sildenafil paypal – viagra from canada no prescription
viagra sale: VGR Sources – viagra comparison prices
sildenafil tablets 120mg: sildenafil generic – buy cheap viagra from india
generic viagra online australia VGR Sources buy female viagra uk
sildenafil tablet brand name in india: VGR Sources – order sildenafil online without prescription
30 mg sildenafil buy online: generic viagra in india – canadian pharmacy sildenafil 100mg
sildenafil 25 mg price in india: where can i purchase sildenafil – best generic viagra prices
75 mg sildenafil female viagra uk viagra cost
order viagra online without script: VGR Sources – order generic viagra online
can you buy viagra over the counter uk: VGR Sources – generic viagra india price
https://vgrsources.com/# buy viagra toronto
viagra.com: can i buy viagra over the counter in india – buy sildenafil generic online
buy viagra safely online uk: where can i buy viagra over the counter – viagra cheap online
order viagra canadian pharmacy canadian viagra prescription viagra pills online order
otc viagra australia: viagra online canada no prescription – sildenafil brand name india
can you buy viagra canada: VGR Sources – can i get viagra without a prescription
where can you buy viagra without a prescription: buy generic viagra australia – cost of 50mg viagra in canada
best price for sildenafil VGR Sources how to order sildenafil online
cheapest online sildenafil: VGR Sources – viagra in india cost
https://vgrsources.com/# viagra without prescriptions
viagra sale: VGR Sources – where can you buy viagra cheap
how can you get viagra over the counter: generic sildenafil 50mg – viagra brand name online
female viagra australia sildenafil price 100mg buy viagra over the counter nz
generic viagra online in usa: best generic viagra – where can i buy generic viagra in canada
sildenafil 200mg price: VGR Sources – buy female viagra canada
sildenafil 100 no prescription: generic viagra canadian pharmacy – sildenafil in india
where can i buy generic viagra in usa: lowest price for generic viagra – viagra online lowest price
female viagra 100mg tablet price in india: VGR Sources – sildenafil 100 mg tablet cost
https://vgrsources.com/# buy cheap sildenafil online uk
viagra pills from india: can you buy sildenafil online – over the counter viagra substitute
viagra soft tabs uk sildenafil australia online sildenafil 100mg buy online us
viagra pills 100 mg: prescription generic viagra – buy canadian sildenafil
order viagra online canada: VGR Sources – where to get female viagra pills
viagra tablet purchase online: generic viagra 150 mg pills – sildenafil generic india
Lipi Pharm amlodipine/atorvastatin Atorvastatin online pharmacy
LipiPharm: para que sirve lipitor – Generic Lipitor fast delivery
LipiPharm: side effects of stopping lipitor – No RX Lipitor online
SemagluPharm: SemagluPharm – Rybelsus 3mg 7mg 14mg
https://prednipharm.com/# Predni Pharm
henry semaglutide reviews Semaglu Pharm SemagluPharm
PredniPharm: PredniPharm – PredniPharm
Online pharmacy Rybelsus: Rybelsus for blood sugar control – Semaglutide tablets without prescription
PredniPharm: 5 prednisone in mexico – Predni Pharm
Rybelsus side effects and dosage: SemagluPharm – Semaglu Pharm
lipitor and joint pain does atorvastatin cause erectile dysfunction lipitor vs simvastatin
https://prednipharm.com/# online order prednisone 10mg
Rybelsus for blood sugar control: Semaglu Pharm – rybelsus doses
Lipi Pharm: п»їBuy Lipitor without prescription USA – Affordable Lipitor alternatives USA
Rosuvastatin tablets without doctor approval: Safe online pharmacy for Crestor – Crestor Pharm
LipiPharm LipiPharm Generic Lipitor fast delivery
Semaglu Pharm: No prescription diabetes meds online – Semaglu Pharm
https://prednipharm.shop/# 50 mg prednisone tablet
Predni Pharm: PredniPharm – PredniPharm
prednisone no rx 1250 mg prednisone prednisone pack
why am i gaining weight on semaglutide: SemagluPharm – rybelsus for prediabetes