VAT case relating to ‘single supply’ and zero rated printed material

The Upper Tribunal decision in Metropolitan International Schools Limited (UKUT0431) deals, among other things, with the issue of determining the VAT treatment of a single indivisible supply where there appears to be more than one element.

This decision is interesting in that it overturned the First-Tier Tribunal’s decision on this point, but not owing to a failure to deploy the correct legal tests, but rather a perceived failure to weigh up the factual position as fully (or accurately) as it ought.  This therefore is one of those rare cases where the finding of fact is effectively disputed by the Upper Tribunal, despite the First Tribunal being ostensibly the forum in which facts are irremediably established.

*Update*: Metropolitan International Schools Ltd was granted permission to appeal on the sole point that the UT misinterpreted the scope of section 84(10) of the  VATA. The Court of Appeal has dismissed this appeal.

The issue was whether this (commercial) college made standard rated supplies of ‘education’ (not being an eligible body for the exemption) or zero rated supplies of printed texts and manuals.  The First Tribunal approached this by looking at what actually was provided, and held that, as things turned out, almost all of what was provided were the texts.  The students sat exams with other providers, so the supply appeared to the First Tribunal as being restricted to an overwhelmingly print-oriented supply.

The Upper Tribunal did not believe that this took sufficient account of what the supplier offered or what it held out as the nature of the offer.  It looked at the components that were delivered without considering, sufficiently, what a customer thought they would get from their purchase.  Even though the education was overwhelmingly delivered through printed material, the customer was offered access to a tutor, to some internet interaction, and some other small enhancements.  The Upper Tribunal thought that this shifted the perspective onto a supply of ‘education’ notwithstanding that the main delivery channel of this, by far, was printed material.  The failure to consider an objective customer’s ‘take’ on his purchase was a major omission in the First Tribunal’s reasoning, so HMRC’s appeal was allowed.

The lesson from this is that reliance on the predominant characteristic of a supply being a relieved category (whether zero rated, reduced rated, or exempt) where there are standard rated elements, is risky.  Unless one can sustain the view that those elements merely support the customer’s enjoyment of the main relieved category, the point is hard to win.  In this case, the extra elements did not really help the student read the books.  They were minor in extent, but they characterised the supply as being something different.  Although the printed material was of overwhelming physical value in the mix, it was this that supported the wider aim of ‘education’, not the other way around.  This is more the approach taken in the old case of College of Estate Management (though in that case the over-arching supply was exempt).

Charities that have relied on the First Tribunal’s decision in this case will need now to take advice.  Charities should approach any case of relying on a relief for a complex supply with considerable care and take advice.

Comments

  1. Danielemaib says:

    http://biotpharm.com/# Over the counter antibiotics pills

  2. Rodneyacime says:

    buy antibiotics from india Biot Pharm best online doctor for antibiotics

  3. JamesTal says:

    buy antibiotics from canada: Biot Pharm – get antibiotics quickly

  4. CurtisSer says:

    online erectile dysfunction: cheapest ed online – Ero Pharm Fast

  5. Rodneyacime says:

    Ero Pharm Fast Ero Pharm Fast cheap ed treatment

  6. CurtisSer says:

    Over the counter antibiotics for infection: BiotPharm – antibiotic without presription

  7. Rodneyacime says:

    Medications online Australia Discount pharmacy Australia Medications online Australia

  8. CurtisSer says:

    Medications online Australia: PharmAu24 – pharmacy online australia

  9. CurtisSer says:

    buy antibiotics online: BiotPharm – Over the counter antibiotics for infection

  10. CurtisSer says:

    order ed pills: Ero Pharm Fast – ed medications online

  11. CurtisSer says:

    Licensed online pharmacy AU: PharmAu24 – online pharmacy australia

  12. Rodneyacime says:

    where to buy erectile dysfunction pills cheapest erectile dysfunction pills order ed pills

  13. CurtisSer says:

    cheapest antibiotics: buy antibiotics online – antibiotic without presription

  14. Davidhep says:

    https://biotpharm.com/# Over the counter antibiotics for infection

  15. Rodneyacime says:

    Ero Pharm Fast cheapest ed online online erectile dysfunction pills

  16. CurtisSer says:

    best online doctor for antibiotics: buy antibiotics from india – Over the counter antibiotics pills

  17. EugeneRaita says:

    pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne pas cher acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance

  18. IssacWhoff says:

    pharmacie en ligne: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es

  19. Matthewrow says:

    viagra sans ordonnance: Viagra générique en pharmacie – prix bas Viagra générique

  20. Jesusnoile says:

    https://viasansordonnance.shop/# Viagra pas cher inde

  21. EugeneRaita says:

    Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h pharmacie en ligne sans prescription Pharmacie Internationale en ligne

  22. IssacWhoff says:

    acheter kamagra site fiable: acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance – kamagra gel

  23. Matthewrow says:

    cialis generique: Acheter Cialis – cialis prix

  24. Edwardvef says:

    Cialis generique sans ordonnance: Cialis generique sans ordonnance – cialis prix

  25. IssacWhoff says:

    Viagra sans ordonnance 24h: livraison rapide Viagra en France – acheter Viagra sans ordonnance

  26. Matthewrow says:

    Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance: livraison rapide Viagra en France – Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance

  27. EugeneRaita says:

    Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance commander Viagra discretement viagra sans ordonnance

  28. Jesusnoile says:

    http://ciasansordonnance.com/# Acheter Cialis

  29. Edwardvef says:

    Kamagra oral jelly pas cher: pharmacie en ligne livraison europe – kamagra livraison 24h

  30. IssacWhoff says:

    kamagra oral jelly: Kamagra oral jelly pas cher – acheter kamagra site fiable

  31. Matthewrow says:

    kamagra 100mg prix: kamagra gel – kamagra 100mg prix

  32. EugeneRaita says:

    pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance pharmacie en ligne fiable

  33. Matthewrow says:

    pharmacie en ligne france pas cher: Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher – acheter Cialis sans ordonnance

  34. IssacWhoff says:

    acheter medicaments sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne – acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance

  35. Jesusnoile says:

    https://viasansordonnance.com/# livraison rapide Viagra en France

  36. Edwardvef says:

    Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h: Viagra generique en pharmacie – Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance

  37. EugeneRaita says:

    kamagra gel kamagra en ligne kamagra en ligne

  38. Matthewrow says:

    acheter médicaments sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie en ligne

  39. IssacWhoff says:

    viagra en ligne: Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h – acheter Viagra sans ordonnance

  40. EugeneRaita says:

    acheter kamagra site fiable kamagra 100mg prix achat kamagra

  41. Edwardvef says:

    Kamagra oral jelly pas cher: commander Kamagra en ligne – acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance

  42. Matthewrow says:

    cialis generique: cialis sans ordonnance – Cialis pas cher livraison rapide

  43. IssacWhoff says:

    kamagra pas cher: achat kamagra – kamagra livraison 24h

  44. Jesusnoile says:

    https://kampascher.com/# commander Kamagra en ligne

  45. EugeneRaita says:

    Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher commander Cialis en ligne sans prescription

  46. Matthewrow says:

    pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne sans prescription – acheter médicament en ligne sans ordonnance

  47. IssacWhoff says:

    livraison discrete Kamagra: livraison discrete Kamagra – pharmacie en ligne livraison europe

  48. Edwardvef says:

    acheter Cialis sans ordonnance: Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher – cialis generique

  49. EugeneRaita says:

    pharmacie internet fiable France pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne livraison europe

  50. Matthewrow says:

    kamagra livraison 24h: kamagra pas cher – livraison discrète Kamagra

  51. IssacWhoff says:

    prix bas Viagra generique: viagra en ligne – commander Viagra discretement

  52. Jesusnoile says:

    https://kampascher.com/# kamagra livraison 24h

  53. EugeneRaita says:

    pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es Cialis generique sans ordonnance Cialis generique sans ordonnance

  54. Matthewrow says:

    pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – pharmacie en ligne france pas cher

  55. IssacWhoff says:

    Pharmacies en ligne certifiees: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique

  56. Matthewrow says:

    pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne – pharmacie en ligne france pas cher

  57. EugeneRaita says:

    viagra sans ordonnance Viagra generique en pharmacie viagra sans ordonnance

  58. IssacWhoff says:

    Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe: kamagra livraison 24h – kamagra oral jelly

  59. Edwardvef says:

    pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance: acheter medicaments sans ordonnance – pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale

  60. Jesusnoile says:

    https://viasansordonnance.shop/# Viagra sans ordonnance 24h

  61. Matthewrow says:

    Pharmacies en ligne certifiées: acheter médicaments sans ordonnance – Pharmacie Internationale en ligne

  62. EugeneRaita says:

    Acheter Cialis traitement ED discret en ligne Cialis pas cher livraison rapide

  63. IssacWhoff says:

    pharmacie en ligne pas cher: Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe – п»їpharmacie en ligne france

  64. JamesFoory says:

    acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne livraison europe – commander Kamagra en ligne

  65. Edwardvef says:

    pharmacie internet fiable France: pharmacie en ligne sans prescription – Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable

  66. EugeneRaita says:

    Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h viagra en ligne viagra en ligne

  67. IssacWhoff says:

    Pharmacies en ligne certifiees: Pharmacie sans ordonnance – Pharmacie Internationale en ligne

  68. Jesusnoile says:

    https://pharmsansordonnance.com/# pharmacie en ligne

  69. EugeneRaita says:

    acheter medicaments sans ordonnance pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance Pharmacie Internationale en ligne

  70. IssacWhoff says:

    Pharmacies en ligne certifiees: pharmacie en ligne sans prescription – acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance

  71. Edwardvef says:

    acheter Cialis sans ordonnance: cialis prix – Cialis pas cher livraison rapide

  72. IssacWhoff says:

    Viagra generique en pharmacie: Viagra sans ordonnance 24h – livraison rapide Viagra en France

  73. EugeneRaita says:

    Viagra sans ordonnance 24h prix bas Viagra generique Viagra generique en pharmacie

  74. Edwardvef says:

    achat kamagra: livraison discrete Kamagra – pharmacie en ligne fiable

  75. Jesusnoile says:

    http://viasansordonnance.com/# Viagra sans ordonnance 24h

  76. IssacWhoff says:

    acheter Cialis sans ordonnance: cialis prix – Cialis sans ordonnance 24h

  77. Edwardvef says:

    acheter Viagra sans ordonnance: acheter Viagra sans ordonnance – viagra sans ordonnance

  78. IssacWhoff says:

    kamagra livraison 24h: commander Kamagra en ligne – Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe

  79. EugeneRaita says:

    Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher Cialis generique sans ordonnance acheter Cialis sans ordonnance

  80. Edwardvef says:

    prix bas Viagra generique: viagra en ligne – acheter Viagra sans ordonnance

  81. IssacWhoff says:

    kamagra livraison 24h: kamagra gel – kamagra en ligne

  82. Jesusnoile says:

    http://ciasansordonnance.com/# Cialis sans ordonnance 24h

  83. IssacWhoff says:

    acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance: achat kamagra – livraison discrete Kamagra

  84. EugeneRaita says:

    commander Kamagra en ligne kamagra oral jelly pharmacie en ligne france fiable

  85. IssacWhoff says:

    pharmacie en ligne pas cher: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie en ligne pas cher

  86. EugeneRaita says:

    kamagra en ligne acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance kamagra en ligne

  87. Jesusnoile says:

    https://pharmsansordonnance.shop/# trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie

  88. IssacWhoff says:

    achat kamagra: acheter kamagra site fiable – kamagra en ligne

  89. EugeneRaita says:

    acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance achat kamagra kamagra pas cher

  90. IssacWhoff says:

    Viagra generique en pharmacie: Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance – acheter Viagra sans ordonnance

  91. EugeneRaita says:

    pharmacie en ligne sans prescription pharmacie internet fiable France pharmacie en ligne pas cher

  92. IssacWhoff says:

    Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher: Cialis generique sans ordonnance – traitement ED discret en ligne

  93. EugeneRaita says:

    Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance Viagra sans ordonnance 24h suisse commander Viagra discretement

  94. Jesusnoile says:

    https://pharmsansordonnance.com/# pharmacie en ligne livraison europe

  95. IssacWhoff says:

    commander Kamagra en ligne: kamagra pas cher – kamagra livraison 24h

  96. EugeneRaita says:

    viagra sans ordonnance Viagra sans ordonnance livraison 48h Viagra sans ordonnance 24h

  97. IssacWhoff says:

    Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h: pharmacie en ligne france fiable – п»їpharmacie en ligne france

  98. Bradleybrosy says:

    triazolam 0 25 migliore farmacia veterinaria online ozempic online

  99. JosephEases says:

    seresto farmacia online: Confia Pharma – farmacia online polonia

  100. MichaelLek says:

    mГ©dicaments cystite sans ordonnance: tadalafil sans ordonnance – fluocaril bi-fluorГ© 250 mg

  101. DannyHem says:

    https://pharmacieexpress.com/# migpriv sans ordonnance

  102. Williambobre says:

    scalpel pharmacie sans ordonnance: ou acheter du viagra en pharmacie sans ordonnance – trouble de l’eréction traitement sans ordonnance en pharmacie en france

  103. MichaelLek says:

    test online farmacia: atenololo 50 mg prezzo – kestine 10 mg prezzo

  104. Bradleybrosy says:

    inegy 10/20 farmacia online 24h lavare i denti al cane in modo naturale

  105. JosephEases says:

    priligy 30 mg prezzo: Farmacia Subito – deltacortene 25 prezzo

  106. MichaelLek says:

    elatrex principio attivo: dicloreum 150 mg compresse – farmacia online it

  107. DannyHem says:

    http://confiapharma.com/# comprar pastillas anticonceptivas sin receta

  108. Williambobre says:

    farmacia online contrareembolso: farmacia online sicura – comprar en farmacia online opiniones

  109. Bradleybrosy says:

    riopan sospensione orale biochetasi supposte bambini legalon bustine

  110. JosephEases says:

    selexid 200 mg sans ordonnance: Pharmacie Express – vitamine b6 pharmacie sans ordonnance

  111. MichaelLek says:

    acetilcisteina eg 600 mg compresse effervescenti: dibase flaconcini – augmentin compresse prezzo

  112. Bradleybrosy says:

    tachipirina 1000 fiale prezzo epiduo gel 0 3 prezzo dibase 50.000 2 flaconcini prezzo

  113. Williambobre says:

    prix viagra 50mg: Pharmacie Express – trouble de l’eréction traitement sans ordonnance en pharmacie

  114. MichaelLek says:

    cialis sans ordonnance en pharmacie en france: Pharmacie Express – pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance canada

  115. DannyHem says:

    https://pharmacieexpress.com/# anti vomitif pharmacie sans ordonnance

  116. JosephEases says:

    sildenafil viagra: progestГ©rone naturelle, en pharmacie sans ordonnance – cialis generique en ligne

  117. Bradleybrosy says:

    farmacia online viareggio farmacia outlet online farmacia homeopatia online

  118. Williambobre says:

    farmacia pt online: comprar antibióticos sin receta online – fortacin comprar sin receta

  119. MichaelLek says:

    emla crГЁme sans ordonnance: dГ©rivГ© amoxicilline sans ordonnance – viagra femme prix en pharmacie sans ordonnance

  120. Bradleybrosy says:

    mycostatin sospensione orale prezzo farmacia online per animali pentacol gel rettale

  121. JosephEases says:

    antibiotique ordonnance: viagra commander – mal de gorge pharmacie sans ordonnance

  122. Williambobre says:

    ordonnance dermatologue: Pharmacie Express – selexid 200 mg sans ordonnance

  123. MichaelLek says:

    stilnox sans ordonnance prix: peut on avoir de la ventoline en pharmacie sans ordonnance – malarone sans ordonnance

  124. DannyHem says:

    http://confiapharma.com/# se puede comprar progesterona sin receta

  125. Bradleybrosy says:

    comprar viagra online en andorra sin receta comprar rhodogil sin receta farmacia 365 dias online

  126. MichaelLek says:

    tirzГ©patide sans ordonnance: quelle pommade antibiotique sans ordonnance ? – fosfomycine prix sans ordonnance

  127. Williambobre says:

    cbd en pharmacie sans ordonnance: cialis pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance – noréthistérone sans ordonnance

  128. JosephEases says:

    acheter pilule pharmacie sans ordonnance: medicament sans ordonnance infection urinaire – ecbu ordonnance

  129. Bradleybrosy says:

    clexane 6.000 prezzo Farmacia Subito gabapentin 100 mg prezzo

  130. MichaelLek says:

    mounjaro se puede comprar sin receta: pedidos de farmacia online – farmacia online arkopharma

  131. DannyHem says:

    http://pharmacieexpress.com/# meilleur antidГ©presseur sans ordonnance

  132. JosephEases says:

    test mononucleosi farmacia: Farmacia Subito – farmacia monti tiburtini

  133. Bradleybrosy says:

    viagra homme prix en pharmacie traitement otite chien sans ordonnance pharmacie medecin en ligne pour ordonnance

  134. MichaelLek says:

    comprar laurimic sin receta: farmacia online de sevilla – comprar misoprostol sin receta mГ©dica

  135. JosephEases says:

    peut on acheter de l’aspirine sans ordonnance: prix irm sans ordonnance – mГ©dicaments cystite sans ordonnance

  136. MichaelLek says:

    farmacia online madrid cialis: se puede comprar viagra sin receta en argentina 2021 – donde comprar tramadol sin receta

  137. JosephEases says:

    farmacia online 4 estaciones: Confia Pharma – se puede comprar dercutane sin receta

  138. Bradleybrosy says:

    ozempic price deniban 50 mg prezzo laurea magistrale farmacia online

  139. DannyHem says:

    https://pharmacieexpress.com/# pharmacie rhume sans ordonnance

  140. MichaelLek says:

    donde comprar botox sin receta: que viagra se puede comprar sin receta mГ©dica – farmacia online miami

  141. JosephEases says:

    cursos farmacia gratis online: farmacia online spain – se puede comprar ozempic sin receta en espaГ±a

  142. Bradleybrosy says:

    omnic a cosa serve tobral orecchio targin morte

  143. Bradleybrosy says:

    comprar tramadol sin receta Confia Pharma farmacia online italia 24

  144. ThomasFes says:

    farmacia homeopatica online madrid: zithromax farmacia online – enantyum comprar sin receta

  145. MichaelLek says:

    lormГ©tazГ©pam sans ordonnance: tadalafil prix 10mg – acheter kГ©toprofГЁne sans ordonnance

  146. JosephEases says:

    pariet 20 mg prezzo: Farmacia Subito – obispax a cosa serve

  147. Bradleybrosy says:

    opiniones farmacia online farmacia coliseum tienda online maior farmacia online do brasil

  148. ThomasFes says:

    farmacia trieste online: bentelan cane – slowmet a cosa serve

  149. MichaelLek says:

    keppra 500 prezzo: alfuzosina 10 mg prezzo – difosfonal 200 mutuabile

  150. DannyHem says:

    https://pharmacieexpress.shop/# pharmacie ordonnance sans carte vitale

  151. Bradleybrosy says:

    оземпик купить в италии Farmacia Subito rifacol principio attivo

  152. MichaelLek says:

    gastrotuss bustine bugiardino: carelimus unguento prezzo – codice sconto farmacia online

  153. JosephEases says:

    efracea 56 capsule prezzo: Farmacia Subito – gabapentin 100

  154. Bradleybrosy says:

    zimox prezzo Farmacia Subito clavaseptin gatto

  155. MichaelLek says:

    deltacortene 25 prezzo: online farmacia italiani – dirahist prezzo

  156. JosephEases says:

    faire une radio sans ordonnance: coquelusedal enfant sans ordonnance – medicament pour cystite sans ordonnance en pharmacie

  157. Bradleybrosy says:

    test covid sans ordonnance en pharmacie Pharmacie Express etiaxil pharmacie sans ordonnance

  158. DannyHem says:

    https://farmaciasubito.shop/# pillola drospil

  159. MichaelLek says:

    farmacia internacional online viagra: Confia Pharma – puedo comprar ibuprofeno sin receta

  160. JosephEases says:

    el ibuprofeno se puede comprar sin receta: puedo comprar inhalador sin receta – farmacia portugal online bexsero

  161. Bradleybrosy says:

    morniflu ГЁ un antibiotico nadixa crema prezzo viagra prezzo

  162. MichaelLek says:

    condyline sans ordonnance en pharmacie: otite medicament sans ordonnance – mycose pharmacie sans ordonnance

  163. Bradleybrosy says:

    kyleena spirale prezzo oki quanto costa cefixoral 400 prezzo con ricetta

  164. MichaelLek says:

    cosyrel 5/10 prezzo: resilient – zodon soluzione orale

  165. PeterWaw says:

    https://pharmexpress24.shop/# online pharmacy no prescription needed lortab

  166. WilliamJah says:

    http://inpharm24.com/# indian pharmacy

  167. Matthewboose says:

    buy trandate online controlled substances in mexico mexican ativan

  168. Rogerzek says:

    buy online medicine: prescription drugs from india – india pharmacy delivery to usa

  169. Matthewboose says:

    viagra pharmacy prices uk steroids online pharmacy ed meds online

  170. Charlessen says:

    quit smoking: spironolactone online pharmacy no prescription – online pharmacy suboxone

  171. Rogerzek says:

    is mexicanrxpharm legit: mexico tramadol – best canadian pharmacy for us citizens

  172. WilliamJah says:

    https://inpharm24.com/# medications from india

  173. Matthewboose says:

    adderall shipped to me mexico prescription meds antibiotics mexican pharmacy

  174. Rogerzek says:

    india pharmacy online: InPharm24 – medicine from india

  175. Randallfoela says:

    lorazepam indian pharmacy: Pharm Express 24 – us pharmacy viagra prices

  176. Charlessen says:

    history of pharmacy in india: InPharm24 – india pharmacy reviews

  177. Matthewboose says:

    mexican pharmacy list mexican pharmacy prices mexican pharmacy coupon code

  178. Rogerzek says:

    generic cialis uk online pharmacy: 24 7 pharmacy online – ciprofloxacin pharmacy uk

  179. Randallfoela says:

    mexican pharmacy for retin a: mexican online pharmacy prescription drugs – cozumel mexico pharmacy price list

  180. WilliamJah says:

    http://inpharm24.com/# india online pharmacy

  181. Charlessen says:

    clozapine pharmacy registration: Pharm Express 24 – us pharmacy cialis online

  182. Randallfoela says:

    true rx pharmacy: Pharm Express 24 – u s online pharmacy

  183. Rogerzek says:

    indian pharmacies safe: baclofen pharmacy – online pharmacy checker

  184. Matthewboose says:

    online pharmacy cost Pharm Mex cheapest mail order pharmacy

  185. Randallfoela says:

    pharmacy india: medplus pharmacy india – pharmacy website in india

  186. Rogerzek says:

    online pharmacy misoprostol: pharmacy discount – Duricef

  187. Charlessen says:

    best indian pharmacy: medicine from india – pharmacy india online

  188. Matthewboose says:

    vyvanse mexican pharmacy Pharm Mex medications online store

  189. WilliamJah says:

    https://pharmexpress24.com/# mail order pharmacy

  190. Rogerzek says:

    zocor pharmacy protocol: pharmacy logo – rx pharmacy coupons

  191. Matthewboose says:

    mexican pharmacy online oxycodone ozempic mail order pharmacy medication from mexico

  192. Randallfoela says:

    is ozempic otc in mexico: Pharm Mex – mexican ibuprofen

  193. Rogerzek says:

    online india pharmacy: InPharm24 – registration in pharmacy council of india

  194. Matthewboose says:

    the pharmacy norvasc online pharmacy pharmaceutical online

  195. Randallfoela says:

    overseas pharmacy india: order medicine online india – when first pharmacy course was started in india

  196. WilliamJah says:

    http://pharmmex.com/# mexican pharmacy weight loss

  197. Rogerzek says:

    online pharmacy uk prozac: heb online pharmacy – cialis cost at pharmacy

  198. Matthewboose says:

    mexico viagra pills best mexican online pharmacy ozempic mail order pharmacy

  199. AaronWrarf says:

    online pharmacy testosterone cypionate: sams club pharmacy levitra – risperidone online pharmacy

  200. Rogerzek says:

    wholesale pharmacy online: Pharm Mex – tirzepatide available in mexico

  201. Charlessen says:

    trusted online pharmacy cialis: Pharm Express 24 – online animal pharmacy

  202. Matthewboose says:

    mounjaro availability in mexico mexican pharmacy delivery mexican vet pharmacy

  203. Rogerzek says:

    list of pharmacies in india: india medical – e pharmacy india

  204. WilliamJah says:

    http://pharmexpress24.com/# lexapro pharmacy online

  205. Matthewboose says:

    pharmacy website in india online medicine india medicine online shopping

  206. Charlessen says:

    kroger pharmacy tamiflu: online pharmacies no prescription – wegmans pharmacy atorvastatin

  207. Rogerzek says:

    viagra pharmacy india: Pharm Express 24 – anthem online pharmacy

  208. Matthewboose says:

    kamagra pharmacy bangkok steroid online pharmacy giant eagle pharmacy simvastatin

  209. Rogerzek says:

    prescription cialis online pharmacy: publix pharmacy bactrim – mexican veterinary pharmacy online

  210. Matthewboose says:

    which of these items would you buy at la farmacia? medication in mexico online pharmacy list

  211. BrianHurce says:

    viagra online order india: sildenafil generic drug cost – where can i buy cheap generic viagra online

  212. Rodneyunosy says:

    https://vgrsources.com/# viagra generic over the counter

  213. BrandonTib says:

    generic viagra from usa canadian pharmacy viagra 50 mg online pharmacy viagra no prescription

  214. Billycrelp says:

    viagra pills order online: sildenafil otc us – viagra coupon

  215. JamesPhige says:

    sildenafil 50mg: where to buy viagra uk – viagra 100 price

  216. BrianHurce says:

    sildenafil 100 canadian pharmacy: VGR Sources – over the counter female viagra pills

  217. Billycrelp says:

    sildenafil tablets where to buy: viagra fiyatı 50mg – viagra india price

  218. BrandonTib says:

    sildenafil 105 mg canada female viagra mexico sildenafil best price canada

  219. JamesPhige says:

    buying viagra over the counter in usa: where can i order generic viagra online – sildenafil pills canada

  220. Rodneyunosy says:

    https://vgrsources.com/# canadian pharmacy viagra pills

  221. BrianHurce says:

    buy generic sildenafil online: VGR Sources – buy generic sildenafil online

  222. Billycrelp says:

    viagra 2019: order viagra from canada – buy sildenafil without a prescription

  223. JamesPhige says:

    pharmacy viagra canada: viagra online south africa – sildenafil generic mexico

  224. BrandonTib says:

    sildenafil 100mg buy online us viagra pills from india over the counter viagra united states

  225. BrianHurce says:

    100g viagra: VGR Sources – viagra canadian pharmacy

  226. Billycrelp says:

    buy viagra cheapest price: VGR Sources – viagra online south africa

  227. JamesPhige says:

    canada prescription viagra: VGR Sources – viagra uk best price

  228. Rodneyunosy says:

    https://vgrsources.com/# where to buy viagra for women

  229. BrandonTib says:

    can i buy viagra over the counter australia VGR Sources viagra online lowest price

  230. Billycrelp says:

    price of 50 mg viagra: VGR Sources – generic viagra

  231. BrianHurce says:

    buy viagra without rx: viagra online using paypal – sildenafil generic cheap

  232. JamesPhige says:

    cheap canadian viagra online: can i buy viagra without a prescription – where can i buy viagra over the counter uk

  233. BrandonTib says:

    viagra online purchase usa VGR Sources cheap generic sildenafil citrate

  234. Billycrelp says:

    where can you buy generic viagra: VGR Sources – buy viagra united kingdom

  235. BrianHurce says:

    viagra discount online: VGR Sources – is viagra safe

  236. JamesPhige says:

    can you buy viagra otc: price generic viagra – buying sildenafil uk

  237. BrandonTib says:

    cheapest price for generic viagra viagra generic from india sildenafil soft gel capsule

  238. Rodneyunosy says:

    https://vgrsources.com/# viagra gel tabs

  239. BrianHurce says:

    how to viagra: viagra from mexico to us – pharmacy viagra price

  240. JamesPhige says:

    female viagra capsules in india: VGR Sources – buy cheap sildenafil uk

  241. BrandonTib says:

    viagra 100mg tablet price in india online VGR Sources viagra soft pills

  242. Billycrelp says:

    purchase viagra usa: VGR Sources – viagra paypal canada

  243. JamesPhige says:

    viagra without prescription uk: female viagra online india – generic viagra 150 mg online

  244. BrianHurce says:

    viagra for sale without prescription: how much is a viagra prescription – generic viagra online united states

  245. BrandonTib says:

    sildenafil 50 mg canada sildenafil otc us generic viagra soft pills

  246. Billycrelp says:

    viagra generic online canada: can i buy sildenafil citrate – buy viagra medicine online india

  247. Rodneyunosy says:

    https://vgrsources.com/# cheap viagra fast delivery

  248. JamesPhige says:

    cost of sildenafil in canada: VGR Sources – lowest cost viagra online

  249. Billycrelp says:

    how to get viagra prescription online: buy viagra soft online – 100mg viagra cost

  250. BrandonTib says:

    sildenafil best price uk VGR Sources is viagra safe

  251. JamesPhige says:

    viagra 100 mg for sale: buy real viagra online usa – 40 mg sildenafil

  252. BrianHurce says:

    where to buy viagra with paypal: rx pharmacy generic viagra – where to get viagra over the counter

  253. Billycrelp says:

    sildenafil 50mg brand name: VGR Sources – sildenafil generic australia

  254. BrandonTib says:

    cheap sildenafil pills VGR Sources can you buy viagra online uk

  255. Rodneyunosy says:

    https://vgrsources.com/# can i buy female viagra over the counter

  256. JamesPhige says:

    generic viagra india pharmacy: VGR Sources – viagra in india online purchase

  257. BrianHurce says:

    cheap viagra online: VGR Sources – viagra online drugstore

  258. Billycrelp says:

    how much is viagra australia: online pharmacy australia viagra – how to get viagra in mexico

  259. BrandonTib says:

    generic viagra online paypal australia viagra generic viagra 120mg

  260. JamesPhige says:

    20 mg sildenafil cost: VGR Sources – viagra pharmacy india

  261. Billycrelp says:

    viagra gel australia,: viagra super force – online viagra pharmacy

  262. BrianHurce says:

    where do i get viagra: VGR Sources – where to get viagra pills

  263. BrandonTib says:

    sildenafil prescription nz average price of generic viagra buy sildenafil generic online

  264. Rodneyunosy says:

    https://vgrsources.com/# sildenafil buy online without a prescription

  265. JamesPhige says:

    sildenafil prescription canada: compare viagra prices uk – Preis von Viagra 50 mg

  266. BrianHurce says:

    buy viagra now: viagra soft 100mg online canadian pharmacy – otc viagra pills

  267. BrandonTib says:

    viagra online ordering VGR Sources viagra soft tabs online

  268. Billycrelp says:

    buying sildenafil citrate online: VGR Sources – no prescription cheap viagra

  269. JamesPhige says:

    buying viagra: VGR Sources – viagra pills uk

  270. BrianHurce says:

    best price for sildenafil: VGR Sources – sildenafil 100mg price india

  271. BrandonTib says:

    how much is sildenafil 20 mg rx sildenafil tablets viagra capsule price in india

  272. Billycrelp says:

    sildenafil 100mg cost: VGR Sources – order viagra canadian pharmacy

  273. Jamesdem says:

    http://lipipharm.com/# Lipi Pharm

  274. Billyploro says:

    PredniPharm: PredniPharm – where can you buy prednisone

  275. Albertoroalm says:

    SemagluPharm Semaglu Pharm Semaglu Pharm

  276. Estebanfon says:

    cost of atorvastatin 80 mg without insurance: LipiPharm – lipitor and grapefruit

  277. Alfonsolus says:

    Lipi Pharm: Order cholesterol medication online – lipitor best time to take

  278. Billyploro says:

    side effects of semaglutide shots: SemagluPharm – SemagluPharm

  279. Estebanfon says:

    PredniPharm: prednisone 10mg price in india – prednisone 50 mg tablet cost

  280. Jamesdem says:

    http://semaglupharm.com/# Rybelsus 3mg 7mg 14mg

  281. Albertoroalm says:

    LipiPharm does lipitor cause dementia LipiPharm

  282. Alfonsolus says:

    Semaglu Pharm: Online pharmacy Rybelsus – SemagluPharm

  283. Billyploro says:

    Semaglu Pharm: SemagluPharm – rybelsus without diabetes

  284. Estebanfon says:

    rosuvastatin coupon walgreens: Buy cholesterol medicine online cheap – Crestor Pharm

  285. Alfonsolus says:

    LipiPharm: Atorvastatin online pharmacy – Lipi Pharm

  286. Albertoroalm says:

    prednisone 40 mg tablet PredniPharm PredniPharm

  287. Jamesdem says:

    http://lipipharm.com/# lipitor uses

  288. Estebanfon says:

    Lipi Pharm: cholesterol lipitor – Lipi Pharm

  289. Alfonsolus says:

    Lipi Pharm: LipiPharm – LipiPharm

  290. Billyploro says:

    Rybelsus online pharmacy reviews: is tirzepatide better than semaglutide – rybelsus use for

  291. Albertoroalm says:

    Lipi Pharm LipiPharm atorvastatin and clopidogrel side effects

  292. Alfonsolus says:

    can you take rosuvastatin with paxlovid: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm

  293. Albertoroalm says:

    LipiPharm USA-based pharmacy Lipitor delivery Lipi Pharm

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *